Live data from Hacker News

LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

browsergate.eu

781–790 of 836 posts

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#781
post #775

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And you should be trusted because… You state a lot, but not once you give even the slightest proof to your claims. Call me doubtful at best.

If you expect a reply from the damage control team, you'll be disappointed.

I would never expect that. But I am not even sure, it is from anyone at LinkedIn (at least in an official position).

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#782
What's really weird about this list is what's not there.

I'm not seeing my spicy extensions (e.g. BPC), or the ones I use to block content on LinkedIn (ViolentMonkey, Ublock). So this isn't about detecting what they might deem as bad behaviour.

Nor could it be a fingerprinting thing, right? You'd want a full list for a full ID.

But they are checking out your religion. Deeply creepy.

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#783

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are transfering moral agency from yourself, to the government. Will you do the same for your kids ? WOuld you let the government decide for you whats right, and what's wrong ?

Regulation does not necessarily need to be about deciding what's right and what's wrong. It's about making life better for people. That's supposed to be why we have government. If they are not improving people's lives, why do we even have them? Too many people see the government doing nothing to improve their lives and think there's totally nothing wrong with that.

I fail to see how some of the octogenarians in DC, who are making a kiling for decades in trading on market moves that they initiate/regulate themselves, are making life better for your family, or mine.

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#784
post #551

A few years ago, intentionally fingerprinting or tracking your users without disclosure was spyware and unethical. Alas, here we are. Anyway, what they're calling "spectroscopy", is a combination of extension probing and doing residue detection (looking for what extensions might leave behind in the DOM). An ad blocker is not necessarily equipped to help since the script is embedded with the application code. Since th…

By GDPR this is illegal. But I assume no action will be forthcoming

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#785
Ever since the scraping lawsuits [0] I realized linked-in has adopted the "I take all your data, you take none of mine" idea to another level.

Also the site doesn't even work well and is one of the main examples of "dark patterns" on the web [1].

Literally one of the worst companies and websites out there. Stallman has a summary of the additional reasons [2].

[0] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/12/eff-court-accessing-pu...

[1] https://medium.com/@danrschlosser/linkedin-dark-patterns-3ae...

[2] https://www.stallman.org/linkedin.html

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#786
post #389

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> These two sentences highlight the underlying problem: Developers without an ethical backbone, or who are powerless to push back on unethical projects. What the article describes should not be "what many devs would land on" naturally. What many devs should land on is "scanning the user's browser in order to try to fingerprint him without consent is wrong and we cannot do it." I think using LinkedIn is pretty much ag…

The difference is between the data you give out voluntarily and what is taken from you without consent

If you voluntarily visit my website and my web server sends a response to your IP address, have I “taken” your IP address, or did you give it to me “voluntarily”? What if I log your IP address?

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#787

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> this is why I run ad blockers. It's pretty wild that we live in a world where the actual FBI has recommended we use ad blockers to protect ourselves, and if everyone actually listened, much of the Internet (and economy) as we know it would disappear. The FBI is like "you should protect yourself from the way that the third largest company in the world does business", and the average person's response is "nah, that w…

>the average person's response is "nah, that would take at least a couple of minutes of my time, As a data point I, a technical person who tweaks his computer a lot, was against adblocking for moral reasons (as a part of perceived social contract, where internet is free because of ads). Only later I changed mi mind on this because I became more privacy aware.

[dead]

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#788
post #752

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So essentially a bunch of noise that didnt really mean anything concrete?

Mozilla backed down due to the backlash. It still means Mozilla is untrustworthy.

This implies they had some sinister plan to claim all your data as theirs or something which is ridiculous - they didn’t back down from anything but changed the wording of the legal text to make it easier to parse for non-lawyers.

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#789
This is a good reminder of how much trust we implicitly place in every website we visit. Most people have no idea that a site can silently probe their browser environment while they're just trying to scroll their feed. Even if LinkedIn's intent is benign (fraud detection, fingerprinting), the lack of transparency is what makes it feel wrong. You shouldn't have to inspect network traffic to know what a website is doing with your data.

Re: LinkedIn is searching your browser extensions

#790

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Scanning your computer is an entirely different thing than scanning browser extensions. By maximizing the expectation via "Illegally searching your computer", the truth suddenly appears harmless.

Where do browser extensions exist? I've got a dreadful feeling they might be on my computer.

Similarly, CSS font fallbacks are when websites break into your computer and steal your data, just because their font didn’t load!
Post reply on HN