Here’s an actual hot take compared to the sentiment in this discussion: this will be the best selling iPhone ever. Specs wise sure, I’d also love a bigger battery than it being thin*. But the iPhone has been an unbelievable fashion statement, and this insanely sexy iPhone will be the strongest yet. I’m pretty sure when it comes out, people will actually hold it in their hands and the sentiment will turn. Not talking…
I think the price point above the 17 and close to the 17 Pro gives it less appeal, but I guess it does make it more "premium" too.
I definitely don't think you're out of left field.