Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

windowscentral.com

761–770 of 774 posts

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#761

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Mozilla has the hardcore geeks on their side. Even during the V30 to v50 transition period where Firefox was, at the time, clearly an inferior product, we kept using it to support it for the sheer ideal of it. We hoped it would come back from it, and it happened: Firefox is now a fast, lean and fantastic browser again. I use Firefox. I always have. My experience is totally different to yours. Before FF57 it was a s…

I said "during the V30 to v50 transition period where Firefox was, at the time, clearly an inferior product", compared to the competition, not anterior version of itself. The later is a more complicated matter, as it was 10 years ago, with different expectations, hardware, user base and web.

And I pointed out that prior to v57 FF was a clearly superior product to the competition for me. For me FF v52 was also superior to v57. Sadly v52 is now out of support and the result is that I had to get a new computer.

For me the order of utility is FF pre v57 > FF post v57 > Chromium based browsers.

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#762
post #430

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Chrome didn’t come to dominate the desktop browser market by forcing users’ hand, but by offering a better experience. The few times I used Edge, nothing gave me a remotely better experience, I only noticed small annoyances and moved on.

> Chrome didn’t come to dominate the desktop browser market by forcing users’ hand, but by offering a better experience . That, and popping up that "works better in chrome!" thing on every one of their web properties for a few years.

The way you phrase this almost suggests there isn't still an obnoxious pop-up partially obscuring search results every single time you go a Google Search while not logged in with a competing browser to this day.

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#763

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Chrome didn’t come to dominate the desktop browser market by forcing users’ hand, but by offering a better experience . That, and popping up that "works better in chrome!" thing on every one of their web properties for a few years.

The way you phrase this almost suggests there isn't still an obnoxious pop-up partially obscuring search results every single time you go a Google Search while not logged in with a competing browser to this day.

Yeah, I should have been more clear. You are right, they are most certainly /still/ doing it.

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#764

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Many of you here don't test your own work in Edge. This is at least partly self-inflicted damage by Microsoft. Edge only works on Windows 10, which not only excludes all of the regular Win 7 and 8 desktops that haven't been push upgraded, but also kiosk-type devices and at least some VDI (which use Windows Server with a "Desktop Experience" that does not include Edge). So Microsoft ended up with IE11, which is supp…

You can test against IE and Edge for free with VM images from Microsoft.

You can, but all of those issues apply to user desktops, and they won't run VMs. There's no advantage to anybody apart from Windows-only corporate system administrators to even try to work with Microsoft browsers right now.

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#765

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It just depends on how far you're trying to push these browsers. Chrome has a lot of crazy cutting edge APIs which allow amazing developer and therefore user experiences. For example, IntersectionObserver, which allows developers to know when a part of a page is active, and respond accordingly; Safari doesn't even implement IntersectionObserver, even though it's been a standardized spec since like 2013. It might seem…

Intersection Observer is being developed for Safari/WebKit: https://webkit.org/status/#?search=intersection

Intersection Observer is on by default in Safari Technology Preview now: https://webkit.org/blog/8517/release-notes-for-safari-techno...

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#766
post #690
post #486

Earlier quoted context omitted.

(Hint: you don't) I'm a web developer with an Android smartphone and Ubuntu as my main OS, Windows as my secondary. My primary means of testing on iOS/Safari is to be very careful about which features I target by checking caniuse.com and the JS compatibility list. And that doesn't protect you against iOS randomly doing something stupid like pretending to give you access to localStorage in private browsing mode but ac…

Exactly. And only because most web developers are doing their job and work around all those annoying little bugs in Safari /that never seem to get fixed), the average Safari user thinks it is an entirely usable browser.

Or more specifically, because so many web developers use Macs and therefore Safari (or have superiors that use Macs and Safari) day to day and don't have to do any explicit testing to find those bugs.

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#767
post #731
post #113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not even close. IE6 was a browser that was set in stone. It only ran on Windows. It's legacy that we live with today is the ActiveX controls that are basically parts of Windows. MS stopped innovating on the browser part of IE6 and focused on ActiveX e.g. native Windows components that you could use in the browser. You can't talk about IE6 and not mention how embedded it was with Windows. That is what made IE6 bad. Yo…

This reaction is pretty interesting. I was doing some webdev back then, and whilst everything you said was true it was the lack of cross browser CSS and Javascript testing which led to the real frustration. Back in 2002/03 IE6 had over 90% marketshare, and justifying testing in anything else was a constant battle.

As developer back then I had the same experience but with some reflection ie 6 was the better browser in 2002 - Firefox css got better but that was more like 2005 after many years of zero development on IE6. Reflecting back to that time period the most lasting damages were active x. There are still governments and corporations that can’t migrate from IE 11 because of this legacy.

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#768

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I'm with you on the variety side, lest not forget that Chromium is at least open source, permitting other vendors to do a move like this instead of being left in the cold (and in this way probably committing back to the project). The flip side here is that building a fully featured browser engine from scratch that is "just" good enough to render 80% of pages correctly is a herculean, almost impossible task in 2…

> building a fully featured browser engine from > scratch that is "just" good enough to render 80% > of pages correctly is a herculean, almost impossible > task in 2018. Absolutely! > I think we're already well off with two fully > featured and completely open source browser engines. Well, that's the problem. The death of Edge brings us one step closer to a browser monoculture. Which is apparently something developer…

This is my point distilled exactly.

It doesn't matter if HN uses Firefox. It doesn't matter if web developers like us the world over use Firefox.

Ezra and Taylor just want to manage their personal brands and don't care about all that nerd stuff.

We'll build for where the audience is, and they're not going to switch for any of the reasons in this thread. It works good enough as it is.

Yes, Chrome is open source, but in marketing/critical mass terms this is no different than last time.

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#769

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not really better though - having only two real browsers is not good for open standards or the open web. This will be especially true when Firefox inevitably shutters it's in-house efforts in a couple of years due to the amount of sites that won't work with it , and starts using Chromium too. Staring into my crystal ball tells me Firefox will become "janky" in the eyes of users on account of how many sites don't…

You seems very certain that Firefox will switch to Chromium but the recent trend is going in the exact opposite direction : - Firefox Focus is switching from Chromium Engine to Gecko Engine. - Huge amount of work in WebRender, they're starting to test it. If it lives up its promise Chromium Engine might fall far behind in terms of performance. So maybe you're right but from what we can tell right now, the current tre…

Cool. I'd love to be dead wrong about this, it's just that history is tempering my optimism.

I feel like Debbie Downer from SNL back in the day, so let's hope you're right.

Re: Microsoft is building a Chromium browser to replace Edge on Windows 10

#770

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not to mention that fixing it for one browser may well break it for another. Usually it leads to compromising but even then still favouring one browser (usually Chrome) over another.

This is my biggest gripe with Edge/IE. - Build some webapp and get it working correctly in Chrome - Test on Firefox. It works 90% of the time. 9% of the time it's relatively easy to support. 1% of the time it isn't worth the hassle. - Test on Edge. It works 80% of the time. 10% it's an easy enough fix. 10% you have to move heaven and Earth to fix and when you contact Microsoft, they know about the issue but won't do…

I want to print this and stick it up on the wall by my desk.
Post reply on HN