Live data from Hacker News

GPT-5 is behind schedule

wsj.com

701–710 of 1001 posts

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#701

I have to say I finally "caved in" to LLMs last month. While I still think Copilot is useless, I recently had a very complex code that did a lot of crazy bit-flipping and xoring, and I had no idea what is it doing, so I threw it to ChatGPT.. and it knew what it was doing. I also needed to rewrite this code to PHP (for... reasons) while I know very little PHP. And it did that! It was a bit wrong, I needed to correct a…

That's basically my experience. It's great for learning or getting things done when the subject is related to one you know well (i.e. you understand the fundamentals and can verify responses quickly).

It's not so good for a completely new subject, or one you have a lot of experience in.

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#702
Out of Claude and GPT, only Claude asks me questions if it does not fully "know" something, be it the matter at hand or my intentions. I think this is a good way to avoid "hallucinations". GPT just keeps spouting whatever it can.

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#703

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> 60% of gen Z men are single, 30% women I always do a double take when I read such statistics. How can they possibly add up? Are gen Z men considered particularly undesirable leading to lots of relationships with large age gaps? Is there a ridiculously large overhang of gay women (over men)? Is there a huge number of men with multiple partners? These gender disparities are difficult enough to believe when they come…

I think I recall that being somewhat disputed because the relationship status was self reported, some suggested that men might not consider certain types of relationships as serious but women do, so there's a disparity in reporting what is and isn't an actual relationship and the reality might be more balanced. Sweden statistics, xd. From what I can find after a brief search, there's this one [0] that claims 63% for…

So are you saying, some gen Z men are in a relationship, but don't know it? I do buy that, it seems to be the basis of some rom-com plots. The clueless guy that doesn't know he's being reeled in.

Other factor.

As the other post suggested. There are large age gaps. Women date older, men date younger. This is also long known. Does it add up to 60/30? That does seem high, but maybe with every other factor thrown in, it explains it?

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#704

Earlier quoted context omitted.

(throwaway account because of what I'm about to say, but it needs to be said) While my main use case for LLMs is coding just like most people here, there are lots of areas that are being ignored. Did you know llama 3.X models have been trained as psychotherapists? It's been invaluable to dump and discuss feelings with it in ways I wouldn't trust any regular person. When real therapists also cost more than what people…

This seems to be part of a side plot in Blade Runner 2049. The movie was about replicants of course, but in the background, the technology shown with the AI being a companion, it was a huge corporate hit, a big seller. In the background you see ad's for it, and they reference it as their most popular product. And, as you allude to, in the movie it was both for loneliness AND sexual. They interacted like a relationshi…

I thought it is, with CSAM.

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#705

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So LLMs are unreliable experts, okay. They're still useful if you understand their particular flavor of unreliability (basically, they're way too enthusiastic) - but more importantly, I bet you have exactly zero human experts on speed dial. Most people don't even know any experts personally, much less have one they could call for help on demand. Meanwhile, the unreliable, occasionally tripping pseudo-experts named GP…

> Most people don't even know any experts personally, much less have one they could call for help on demand. Most people can read original sources.

How do you even know what original sources to read?

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#706

I'm sure the debate over the definition of AGI is important and will continue for a while, but... I can't care about it anymore. Between Perplexity searching and summarizing, Claude explaining, and qwen (and other tools) coding, I'm already as happy as can be with whatever you want to call this level of intelligence. Just today I used a completely local AI research tool, based on Ollama. It worked great. Maybe it won…

completely local AI research tool, based on Ollama Could you elaborate? Was it easy to install?

Yes I was referring to this:

https://github.com/TheBlewish/Automated-AI-Web-Researcher-Ol...

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#707
post #548

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A Scientific American issue where the authors have no idea that they don’t know a topic so just completely make up the content, including the sources. At least magazine authors are reading the sources before misunderstanding the content (or asking the authors what the research means). I don’t even trust the summaries after watching LLMs think we have meetings about my boss’s cat just because I mentioned it once as sh…

Its good to not trust it but that's not the same as it having no idea . There is a lot of value in being close for many tasks!

> There is a lot of value in being close for many tasks!

horseshoes and hand-grenades?

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#708

I'm sure the debate over the definition of AGI is important and will continue for a while, but... I can't care about it anymore. Between Perplexity searching and summarizing, Claude explaining, and qwen (and other tools) coding, I'm already as happy as can be with whatever you want to call this level of intelligence. Just today I used a completely local AI research tool, based on Ollama. It worked great. Maybe it won…

> Just today I used a completely local AI research tool, based on Ollama. It worked great.

Is it on github?

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#709

I'm sure the debate over the definition of AGI is important and will continue for a while, but... I can't care about it anymore. Between Perplexity searching and summarizing, Claude explaining, and qwen (and other tools) coding, I'm already as happy as can be with whatever you want to call this level of intelligence. Just today I used a completely local AI research tool, based on Ollama. It worked great. Maybe it won…

Curious about the AI research tool you mentioned, would you mind sharing it? Been trying to get a good local research setup with Ollama but still figuring out what works best.

https://github.com/TheBlewish/Automated-AI-Web-Researcher-Ol...

Re: GPT-5 is behind schedule

#710

Earlier quoted context omitted.

vscode + cline extension + gemini2.0 is pretty awesome. Highly recommend checking out cline. it quickly became one of my favorite coding tools.

Gemini 2.0 isn't particularly great at coding. The Gemini 1206 preview that was released just before 2.0 is quite good, though. Still, it hasn't taken the crown from Claude 3.5 Sonnet (which appears to now be tied with o1). Very much agree about Cline + VSCode, BTW. My preferred models with Cline are 3.5 Sonnet and 3.5 Haiku. I can throw the more complex problems at Sonnet and use Haiku for everything else. https://a…

In the wake of the o1 release, and with the old aider benchmark saturating, Paul from aider has created a new, much harder benchmark. o1 dominates by a substantial margin.

https://aider.chat/docs/leaderboards/ https://aider.chat/2024/12/21/polyglot.html

Post reply on HN