Live data from Hacker News

How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

blog.okcupid.com

71–80 of 102 posts

Re: How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

#71

So many statistics. So little statistical significance testing. This tells me much about this service.

I'm not sure it's valid to infer that their entire service is poor from these series of rather niche blog posts.

(Although saying that, I wonder if this series of theirs is to attract press attention? If so, then it would be nice to see some significance data.)

Re: How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

#72
post #8

Really-really interesting. I'm curious why asian females scored worst of all when asian males scored descent.

The differences on the race graph are so small as to be insignificant.

Nope; the differences on the zodiac graph are.

Differences on the race graph want to tell us something. Not necessarily something relevant, but something, anyway.

Re: How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

#73
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It's 'interesting' but not 'rigorous'. Of course it's not rigorous. To some degree people interacting with OKCupid's site are a self-selecting bunch. You really need to take this at face value. This is just a blog post showing some number crunching on their site. There are no sensationalist headings like "Muslim Males the Most Hated Group of People." Keep in mind that this is also not a scientific journal, not peer…

It's way past my bedtime here, and judging by the moderation I'm not able to make my point, which is simply this: If you are going to be making sweeping statements about people, even including race and religion then you really should do your homework, or if you're doing it out of curiosity, keep the results to yourself. By presenting the data in a format that looks as though very hard work went in to its creation and…

I disagree, the data was very interesting and it would be pity if they didn't release it.

Re: How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

#74

Am I the only one who had a good chuckle at the zodiac grid?

I was laughing before that with this:

> ". . . I point this out now so that, below, when we claim that Jewish women are easier to get along with than Christians, you don’t blame us, you blame Jesus."

Re: How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

#75

Am I the only one who had a good chuckle at the zodiac grid?

Nope, hilarious.

And that's the first really solid evidence that I've seen shared that zodiac signs are utter BS, which makes me doubly grateful to them. Something to point to when someone says it can't be proved otherwise...

Re: How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

#76
post #7

I liked this on a few different levels: -Hacking data to reveal the answers to important difficult questions. -Exploring contentious issues in a neutral & intelligent way. -Great example of how to attract potential customers by providing valuable information that also gently demonstrates competence related to your service & differentiates your offering from competitors. I enjoyed reading this, I learnt something, and…

I don't think it is really as neutral as it seems. Match percentage is a very preliminary survey of how compatible two people are, and the article itself is fairly judgmental.

Re: How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

#78
post #25

I'm loving this blog. Have we seen match percent vs reply rate anywhere?

I think this is probably too biased, as messages from users with a close match percentage are highlighted in your "inbox". The data might not be good enough to discern between "replied to message because it was highlighted" and "replied to message becuase match % was high".

(Personally, I have a feeling that "pretty profile picture" is more influential than "high match %". But of course, it's very hard to measure what one considers physically attractive.)

Re: How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

#79

go jews!

The atheists and agnostics beat the jews, however.

actually because of the response of muslim women to jews being more positive than to ath/agn, I think Jewish men overall come out on top.

Combine that with Jewish men who ARE atheists, which is a good number of em, and you've got a super-match. Which all goes to prove what my mother always told me; "I love you."

Re: How Races and Religions Match in Online Dating

#80

Am I the only one who had a good chuckle at the zodiac grid?

Nope, hilarious. And that's the first really solid evidence that I've seen shared that zodiac signs are utter BS, which makes me doubly grateful to them. Something to point to when someone says it can't be proved otherwise...

The best evidence against astrology I've heard came from my college astronomy professor. Basically, due to the precession of the earth on its axis, the constellations are visible at completely different times than they were when astrology was invented. So even if it wasn't BS back then, it sure is now.

http://www.livescience.com/strangenews/your-astronomical-sig...

Post reply on HN