Live data from Hacker News

BBC blocking articles from UK residents

alexwarren.co.uk

71–80 of 106 posts

Re: BBC blocking articles from UK residents

#71
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No but large swaths of the UK probably don't watch BBC1 or BBC2 on a regular basis as they have a sky or cable and I agree with them, they shouldn't need to fund the BBC if they don't use the content. Reports suggest we'd make 6-7 billion on a sell off. Sell it and put the money towards buying back openreach because an infrastructure is what .gov should do, not content. =p

Yes, non-UK residents should note that if you, in the UK, only ever want to watch Japanese wrestling on a paid TV channel, you still need to shell out on a BBC annual licence (145 pounds/$220) or face a nasty penalty. This generates income for the BBC of > 3bn sterling.

I'm told it's easy enough to either ignore them or get them off your back.

Re: BBC blocking articles from UK residents

#73

If you bookmark the JS below you can create a 'button' to convert bbc.com links to bbc.com.nyud.net links as suggested by the OP: javascript:window.location.href=window.location.href.replace("bbc.com","bbc.com.nyud.net"); A better solution would be a greasemonkey script/browser extension but this does the job for now :-)

Chrome extension: http://goo.gl/VsD5s :)

Re: BBC blocking articles from UK residents

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This applies also to BBC Travel, which is run in partnership with Lonely Planet, last I checked. I used to really enjoy those articles, now I never read them because I can't be faffed to proxy up every time...

Lonely Planet was, until very recently, owned by BBC Worldwide.

Which they sold at an £80m loss. How many license fees is that?

Re: BBC blocking articles from UK residents

#75
post #70

So the BBC is... weird. The majority of the operation is a taxpayer-funded public broadcaster with a remit to produce high quality programming for free; but there's a unit called BBC Worldwide whose job it is to battle it out in the red-in-tooth-and-claw world of commercial TV programming, selling BBC programmes overseas and minting money that can then be used to subsidize the public broadcasting component. While thi…

So, are UK residents prevented from looking at bbc.com URLs in case we see/click on any advertising?

No, it's in case the BBC URL substitutes for a UK commercial website.

Re: BBC blocking articles from UK residents

#77
post #69
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The anger by the OP and most of the commenters is misplaced. This is not a decision solely by the BBC Trust, and was not done with the licence players best interest at heart. This is the result of lobbying by newspapers and commercial broadcasters. The theory is that compulsory tax (or license fee) payers money should not be used to compete against commercial interests in anything other than TV broadcasting. In the c…

The BBC has been out of control for a while now. They bought Lonely Planet and sold it at an £80m loss, they claim to provide impartial news coverage but clearly don't, and they have presided over a paedophile scandal that would make the Catholic Church blush.

Ooops - I forgot the £133m they just wasted on a failed IT Project as well.

Re: BBC blocking articles from UK residents

#78
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Surely they can still make the content available even if they're not allowed to promote it on the public services? e.g. I can still buy Doctor Who DVDs in the UK, even if the BBC can't advertise them between programmes.

Not that it invalidates your point, but your example is a bad one - BBC can, and do, advertise DVDs of their own TV series, in between programmes.

They used to advertise their own magazines as well.

Re: BBC blocking articles from UK residents

#79

It's a little like the BBC world service news, which is pretty good (especially compared to sky and cnn and so on), except you can't get it in the UK ... it even has the same presenters that are on the normal BBC 24 News, and 10 o'clock news! It's weird to say the least. But it gets even more weird, as programmes made by the licence pay version of the BBC appear on the world service news. I was watching it a week ago…

Not sure if we're talking about different things, but the BBC World Service radio channel is available on UK DAB.

Just to confuse matters, the World Service Click programme is not the same as the 'regular' BBC News one either.

Re: BBC blocking articles from UK residents

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So the BBC is no longer producing content for BBC 1 and 2 in the UK? Don't be ridiculous.

I never said I didn't like it, I said it was drivel. I'm quite partial to the odd well produced period drama. What I'm trying to say is that recently they tend produce content with a mind to how the US will receive this new content. Dr who, top gear and downton abbey for instance. All of these are popular in the US and while that isn't a bad thing (more money to the BBC to hopefully make more content) what I disagree…

I really don't think Top Gear is produced with a view to the US market.
Post reply on HN