Live data from Hacker News

Redesigning the Save Symbol

branch.com

71–72 of 72 posts

Re: Redesigning the Save Symbol

#71
In my concept of the future there will be no "Save", but instead any input/document will be passively cached locally in volatile storage, and archived incrementally on a non-volatile medium... without any active user input. In which case you'd only need an icon for "New", "Open" and "Delete".

If you're talking about representing a change of state (volatile to non-volatile), then borrow from Chemistry where a change from liquid to gas is represented by an arrow up, and a change from liquid to solid is represented by an arrow down. You could use the Unicode character U+21DF, a symbol that's already on every computer. Inversely you could use U+21DE to indicate "Load".

Re: Redesigning the Save Symbol

#72
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't the standby mode appropriate for power switches that are momentary toggle switches that started in ATX cases, as opposed to the on/off button which would be appropriate for the AT cases, where the switch is an actual power switch?

Yes but you see it in use incorrectly all the time (including in that thread). In fact, the Windows 8 machine I'm on ( shudder ) actually represents "Shut Down" using the standby icon.

When you press the "shut down" button on your computer, it is going into a soft shutdown state. I don't see the problem here. The On/Off icon should be exclusively used for things that physically sever the power source from the device, which no computers do to my knowledge.
Post reply on HN