Live data from Hacker News

When TED Lost Control of Its Crowd

hbr.org

71–80 of 89 posts

Re: When TED Lost Control of Its Crowd

#71
post #2

The "vortex math" talk was removed from TEDx Charlotte's website, but there's a copy here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-oRnhrOf0r0

You mean the Timecube guy is all wrong and really it's a vortex?!

Wouldn't you love to see those two in a gloves-off debate?

Re: When TED Lost Control of Its Crowd

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm surprised more people don't see this. Releasing your music for free is only an advantage if you already have a built-in audience, or if you're something of a first-mover and can benefit from the novelty factor. But then fast-forward a couple of years and find yourself in a situation where everyone is releasing free music, and you don't get any kind of visibility boost for releasing it for free. What you do have i…

Who is going to pay for music they've never heard though? Small artists have to give away their music if they're going to have any chance of breaking out of obscurity.

It starts to get more subtle at that point - for instance, finding ways to let listeners hear the music while still protecting scarcity. In other words, without the listener feeling like they own it. It's the sort of distinction that leads to why an artist would sign up for pandora but not spotify.

Re: When TED Lost Control of Its Crowd

#73
post #7

I stopped caring about TED talks when it became clear that people were more interested in promoting themselves rather than 'ideas worth spreading'. Too many posers looking for that epic photo of them on-stage with the head mic attached.

This used to be a reflection of narcissism, but now it's been beat into the head of anyone who wants to do anything worthwhile: you have to be a promoter; otherwise, don't bother.

Put another way, it used to be that when I saw people saying, "Hey, look at this!" with nothing worthwhile to look at, I assumed they were narcissistic assholes. Why else would they be trying to get me to spend my time on attention that is obviously not worth it? Now I wonder if they're just normal people trying to master a necessary skill. First learn to make people pay attention, and if you're good at that, then do something worthwhile. Otherwise it doesn't matter what you do.

I don't think that's true or ever will be true, but I think there are people who believe it, people who suck at marketing themselves but put all their energy into it instead of something they're good at because they've been taught to believe that marketing savvy is a prerequisite for contributing to society.

Re: When TED Lost Control of Its Crowd

#74

I'm generally of the opinion that TEDx needs to end entirely. TED is a single organizer, not a movement or a cause - its primary contribution to the world is that of exacting, high-quality curation in a world where everyone has a soapbox. TED's usefulness to people is the trust in the brand and the trust in their curation quality - if this is lost TED's main mission has failed. In my opinion, TED has already lost thi…

I agree entirely. Great base. Not sure that it scales well.

Re: When TED Lost Control of Its Crowd

#75
post #3
post #2

The "vortex math" talk was removed from TEDx Charlotte's website, but there's a copy here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-oRnhrOf0r0

The fact that he was reading his entire presentation verbatim should have tipped everybody off in the first minute or so. Nobody who's "at the forefront of the most advanced mathematics ever known to mankind" needs that much notes to talk about it. Shoot, I've never had a prof that needed that kind of help... and they're teaching 2nd year courses.

I've had an algebra professor who lectured by preparing notes for the class and then reading them and writing them on the board verbatim. After particularly difficult proofs he'd sometimes turn around to look at the class, to see if anyone had their hand up, before moving on.

Said professor has made serious contributions to modern algebra and is probably about as close to "the forefront of modern mathematics" as anyone. Not everyone who's good at math is good at lecturing.

Re: When TED Lost Control of Its Crowd

#77
post #52
post #21

If you want 45 minutes of pure nonsense don't worry about his TED talk. Go straight for his videos on YouTube. eg: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tNHvyTIRVjY

This guy seems to be even more confident: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YN2LBO8wig8

That's apparently his teacher. Watching this is more painful than watching Max performing an impromptu trepanning on his right temple with a power drill; at least his madness had an end.

Re: When TED Lost Control of Its Crowd

#78
post #8

>> "they’re setting up ones that feature “experts” in pseudoscience topics like “plasmatics,” crystal healing, and Egyptian psychoaromatherapy, all of which were presented at TEDxValenciaWomen in December 2012. That conference was described by one disappointed viewer as “a mockery...that hurt, in this order, TED, Valencia, women, science, and common sense.” Wow. I'm ashamed to have put 'curated TEDx participant' on m…

> Wow. I'm ashamed to have put 'curated TEDx participant' on my resume. Removed. Depending on what kind of organization you're applying to, that can still be useful.

MLMs? Homeopathy clinic? Scientology knockoff?
Post reply on HN