Live data from Hacker News

Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie

quietbabylon.com

71–80 of 88 posts

Re: Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie

#71

What a thoughtful essay. "But it uses a silly writing device to illustrate a point it could have just made plainly!" Whoa there, critical-thinking-by-the-numbers guy, maybe the article is also about fashion. As a child, I considered style choices a silly and inconsequential distraction from the beautiful truths of the universe: e^(ipi) + 1 doesn't care what I'm wearing, so neither should I, therefore it doesn't matte…

"everyone can look at someone's dress and decide if it's fashionable for their demographic." You may have forgotten where you are discussing this topic. I certainly have no clue whether something is fashionable. I'd be hard pressed to tell you if two colors go together. I do no know if I dress more or less formally than my coworkers, or if my normal clothes present any sort of image. My style is not a conscious rejec…

it is simply some clothes that I've concluded aren't too far outside what I'm expected to wear

This is where you agree with the post you're replying to. The entire decision process of "what I'm expected to wear" is exactly what they're talking about. You're soaking in it, as indifferent as you appear to think you are is just one facet of accounting for fashion's role in your life, which, to be sure, is not absent.

Re: Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie

#72

What a thoughtful essay. "But it uses a silly writing device to illustrate a point it could have just made plainly!" Whoa there, critical-thinking-by-the-numbers guy, maybe the article is also about fashion. As a child, I considered style choices a silly and inconsequential distraction from the beautiful truths of the universe: e^(ipi) + 1 doesn't care what I'm wearing, so neither should I, therefore it doesn't matte…

[deleted]

Re: Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie

#74
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1B people disagree with you.

1B people aren't even asking themselves those questions.

If people didn't think FB was making things more open and connected, then why are they even on the site (and returning frequently)? It may not be YOUR narrow definition of open and connected but clearly they are deriving value from connecting and sharing with their friends and family.

Re: Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie

#75
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1B people disagree with you.

1B people aren't even asking themselves those questions.

If people didn't think FB was making things more open and connected, then why are they even on the site (and returning frequently)? It may not be YOUR narrow definition of open and connected but clearly they are deriving value from connecting and sharing with their friends and family.

Re: Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let's hope other people don't post them for you. At least when email was the main social network, the effects of indiscreet friends and acquaintances didn't usually appear on Google.

Maybe it's to my advantage that I'm not in any kind of closet, but I also don't share my deepest darkest secrets with people I don't trust implicitly.

It's not exactly your "deepest, darkest secrets" you need to be worried about. Do you really want your boss to know your interests? Do you really want your ex-girlfriend to know if you've moved somewhere nearby? Etc.

Re: Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie

#78
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If nothing else, anyone who visits e.g. Silicon Valley and hangs out with geeks there, will quickly start picking out the "geek uniform". I find it funny when fellow geeks thinks they're clueless about fashion, and still manage to dress in very specific ways that makes them recognisable as a group. That is fashion, even if they're not following mainstream fashion. The first time I visited the Bay Area, I stood out li…

For my own clarification, do you mean that, in London, if a developer comes into the office in a dress shirt they stand out as overly formal? Or do you mean if they come in with only a shirt (ie no tie and jacket) they stand out as under-dressed?

Maybe he worked in the London porn industry, and any shirt is over-dressed.

Re: Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie

#79
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe it's to my advantage that I'm not in any kind of closet, but I also don't share my deepest darkest secrets with people I don't trust implicitly.

It's not exactly your "deepest, darkest secrets" you need to be worried about. Do you really want your boss to know your interests? Do you really want your ex-girlfriend to know if you've moved somewhere nearby? Etc.

Sure, why not? If there's anything like that I did care about, Facebook would be none the wiser anyway.

Re: Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It also struck me as written by someone on the East Coast, which appears to be the case (the writer lives in Toronto). Here in Seattle nobody would spend so many words writing about the hoodie. People wear them. Business professionals wear them. Sometimes even CEOs. It's not a symbol, it's just clothing.

I have no idea what geographic location has to do with writing quality; I live near Toronto, I thought it was overwrought and pointless too. You're kind of reinforcing my negative stereotypes of West Coast people.

It's not about writing quality but about clothing. On the West Coast there's far less of an expectation that business professionals should "dress up". If someone is wearing a hoodie in Seattle or Portland it's not something to comment on, lots of people wear hoodies, even CEOs sometimes. From a West Coast perspective commenting on wearing a hoodie seems a bit like commenting about wearing jeans to work.
Post reply on HN