Live data from Hacker News

Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

techfragments.com

71–80 of 83 posts

Re: Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

#71
post #13

I'd love to see a movie demonstrating what this looks like!

Here's a pic http://www.newscientist.com/gallery/dn16585-amazing-mirrors/...

That links also mentions that his amazing 45 deg. FOV side-view mirror is banned in the US, because curved mirrors are illegal in the US. What the hell? Doesn't congress have anything better to do than shoot us all in the foot, repeatedly?

Re: Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

#72
post #41

Not exactly new: http://www.truemirror.com

No, that link is for 2 mirrors. What Prof. Hicks made is a single curved mirror. That is new. That is why his results got published and he was awarded a patent for it. If you had bothered to read the linked article, you'd already understand the distinction.

The curved mirror exhibits distortion at the edges, which doesn't seem to be a problem with the two-mirror approach.

Also the curved mirror doesn't present the image at full size, it appears smaller.

Re: Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

#73
post #6

> When you look in a normal mirror, the image you see of yourself is in reverse. Funny thing: Mirrors don't reverse left and right. They reverse front and back. So this "non-reversing" mirror is actually mapping y to -y, x to -x (Where the mirror is in front of you in the z-direction. Curious. Edit: I believe tomerv below is correct: x is mapping to -x but y is kept the same.

Demonstration time: Write something on a piece of paper. Hold the paper up to the mirror. Now replace that with a transparent piece of plastic.

What is that supposed to demonstrate?

Re: Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

#74
post #36

After knowing the Feynman puzzle, I think this is probably more correctly described as a reversing mirror. If you look into a metal spoon, you'll see both X and Y reversed. So I'm wondering if you could make this mirror simply by only curving the horizontal part. That's kind of what it looks like in the photo. And if so, why didn't someone think of this early? It's quite obvious.

People thought of this before--just place two mirrors at a 90 degree angle. The guy's innovation is to make it very smooth.

Re: Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because most people don't read at all, or read BS (self-help books, how to succeed, cheap thrillers, 50 shades of gray...)

Have you read fifty shades? I find that people like to bag on stuff they've never actually experienced first hand.

Yes. Still crap.

Re: Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

#76
post #48
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Embarrassingly, I listened to a youtube video where a woman read the book aloud (I listened for about 30 pages). She ended up hitting herself in the head about a dozen times because the writing is that awful.

Fifty Shades is pornography for women. IMHO that's the only reason everyone is clutching their pearls about the bad writing. Your typical male pornography storylines/cinematography are much, much worse - and yet they are typically spared the high-brow literary scrutiny.

Maybe because your "typical male pornography storyline/cinematography" is considered neither a "cultural phenomenon" nor "literature", and does not feature in newspapers and magazine reviews...

Male porn is just porn, but "50 shades of gray" is presented as it is a regular book...

Re: Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

#77
post #6

> When you look in a normal mirror, the image you see of yourself is in reverse. Funny thing: Mirrors don't reverse left and right. They reverse front and back. So this "non-reversing" mirror is actually mapping y to -y, x to -x (Where the mirror is in front of you in the z-direction. Curious. Edit: I believe tomerv below is correct: x is mapping to -x but y is kept the same.

I still don't intuitively understand how reversing front to back results in what we perceive as a left/right inversion.

Feynman explains it best: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msN87y-iEx0&t=46

Re: Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because most people don't read at all, or read BS (self-help books, how to succeed, cheap thrillers, 50 shades of gray...)

Have you read fifty shades? I find that people like to bag on stuff they've never actually experienced first hand.

Fifty Shades of Grey is just Jane Eyre rehashed - young virgin falls in love with rich powerful man. Same story, just a little bit more descriptive when it comes to the sex scenes.

Re: Math Professor Invents Non-Reversing Mirror

#79
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Demonstration time: Write something on a piece of paper. Hold the paper up to the mirror. Now replace that with a transparent piece of plastic.

What is that supposed to demonstrate?

That people on HN have too much spare time.
Post reply on HN