Live data from Hacker News

Git at any scale

cursor.com

71–80 of 128 posts

Re: Git at any scale

#71
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just like with climate change, the problems Elon creates don’t go away just because people are reminded of them. He still pushes his agenda, he still has lots of followers who believe his nonsense

[flagged]

Clearly you either don't read the news or a fanboy or some of his stunts and lies does not bother you.

Re: Git at any scale

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Racism? Here's Elon Musk today whining about George Floyd. https://x.com/elonmusk/status/2090483357456990564

I'm not a user of twitter/x/whatever but every. damn. time. I click on an X link it's made me sadder and stupider, and the world a slightly worse place. It's the dirty bathwater of humanity.

Re: Git at any scale

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

To get racist murderer cops out of jail, is the story I read today.

Oh, and let's not forget the million plus people he helped right into the grave: https://www.doge-impact.org/

That doesn't count other consequences of his election interference, of course.

Re: Git at any scale

#74
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

at this point, s3 just means object storage and doesnt mean it actually has to be hosted on aws. theres plenty of other companies that provide s3 compatible storage apis.

APIs, sure, but do they provide the semi-magical consistency, atomicity, durability, and latency guarantees that this depends on?

It depends?

Last time I looked many of the alternatives didn't have as good support for some of the transaction-friendly things like conditional writes.

Hopefully if you're trying to build something complex on top of S3 and have any expectation of potentially needing to run on top of other infra in the future, you know which magic features you need and can see which of them are supported by what vendors/OSS projects. :)

But it's not really that different than doing cool stuff by pushing a bunch of things into Postgres or Kafka or [other thing] and not explaining how those things work.

Re: Git at any scale

#75
post #62
post #52

There's nothing Cursor can do that GitHub/Microsoft can't in 2026... And vice versa... after several years of Cursor vibecoding a GitHub clone while catching up with GitHub's new features. Git's performance it's not the issue; it's GitHub Actions, PRs, etc. The moment Cursors steals paid GitHub customers and gets the same workloads, they will start having similar issues! Stealing engineers who couldn't fix this at Gi…

Perhaps you didn't read the article, but the implementation they describe is interesting and perhaps easier implemented in a new project from scratch. It can't be any worse than current github, and since we've heard plenty of people express their dissatisfaction with github recently, this is actually a good direction for Cursor. A product people may want. We'll see.

> It can't be any worse than current github

Yeah, and the grass is always greener somewhere else.

The only way to finally end up in a happy state about your git hosting and automated workflows running, is by running the whole shebang yourself. Saves you so much sanity in the long-term, even if starting and scaling is slower.

Re: Git at any scale

#76
post #10

There’s a trend of doing impressive things by pushing many of the hard problems into S3 and assuming S3 “just works”, then not bothering to explain how S3 works. I guess we do the same thing all the time with other miraculous solutions to hard problems, like assuming that superscalar out-of-order processors “just work”, but in cases like this it makes for an unsatisfying explanation. Especially because S3 is a propri…

The product is proprietary, but the interface and semantics are documented and freely available. "S3-compatible object store" is a commodity at this point, so it makes sense to treat it as a primitive building block for a distributed system. Of course, each implementation will have its own set of idiosyncrasies and limitations, so you'll still have to make sure that any such divergent behavior doesn't interfere with your own system requirements.

Re: Git at any scale

#77
post #10

There’s a trend of doing impressive things by pushing many of the hard problems into S3 and assuming S3 “just works”, then not bothering to explain how S3 works. I guess we do the same thing all the time with other miraculous solutions to hard problems, like assuming that superscalar out-of-order processors “just work”, but in cases like this it makes for an unsatisfying explanation. Especially because S3 is a propri…

This was the thing that caught my attention. It does feel like a lot of "scaling git was hard and complicated, so we're just offloading a significant to a different layer"

I've got no dog in this fight and no specific rationale, but it smells like a shortcut that's going to make some assumptions that might surprise later (maybe not at the global level, but a local level)

Re: Git at any scale

#78
post #10

There’s a trend of doing impressive things by pushing many of the hard problems into S3 and assuming S3 “just works”, then not bothering to explain how S3 works. I guess we do the same thing all the time with other miraculous solutions to hard problems, like assuming that superscalar out-of-order processors “just work”, but in cases like this it makes for an unsatisfying explanation. Especially because S3 is a propri…

The product is proprietary, but the interface and semantics are documented and freely available. "S3-compatible object store" is a commodity at this point, so it makes sense to treat it as a primitive building block for a distributed system. Of course, each implementation will have its own set of idiosyncrasies and limitations, so you'll still have to make sure that any such divergent behavior doesn't interfere with…

Less of a commodity at this point than a few years ago, what with Minio immolating itself to be reborn as, excuse my French, AIStor.

Which is not to say that TFA’s approach is invalid or uninteresting, but the mechanics of how “an S3” works are really obscure to those of us not in the know.

Re: Git at any scale

#80
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just like with climate change, the problems Elon creates don’t go away just because people are reminded of them. He still pushes his agenda, he still has lots of followers who believe his nonsense

[flagged]

"Remigration" will improve humanity?

You either know this, or willfully ignore. Can't say which is worse.

Post reply on HN