Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 177 posts

Re: Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

#71
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

on the topic, I dare ask for an invite to lobste.rs if someone has one lying around. I promise I won't be an ass. (Cause a week ago I reached the threshold of wanting to leave a comment enough times)

invite just sent..

I'd appreciate an invite too, if you still have any and are willing to share.

jerod dot santo at gmail dot com

Re: Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

#72

Programming Reddit (Proggit) is more focused on programming (as opposed to politics, tech startups) and therefore, I would argue, is more likely to have the sorts of links you're looking for. But, in my experience, the quality of discussion is lower (though quite high in absolute standards) and you're more likely to have a good comment downvoted.

I quit proggit about a year ago because it was absolutely jammed with politics, tech startups and the like.

To the point where I founded a circlejerk sub to mock it.

Re: Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

#73

Programming Reddit (Proggit) is more focused on programming (as opposed to politics, tech startups) and therefore, I would argue, is more likely to have the sorts of links you're looking for. But, in my experience, the quality of discussion is lower (though quite high in absolute standards) and you're more likely to have a good comment downvoted.

r/ProgrammingLanguages/ is about programming lanugage design, although it doesn't get a lot of traffic.

Re: Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

#74

Programming Reddit (Proggit) is more focused on programming (as opposed to politics, tech startups) and therefore, I would argue, is more likely to have the sorts of links you're looking for. But, in my experience, the quality of discussion is lower (though quite high in absolute standards) and you're more likely to have a good comment downvoted.

"and you're more likely to have a good comment downvoted." This has never made sense to me. On some subreddits that focus on disciplines (like AskHistorians among many others), you can easily get downvoted (ie "dissapeared") just by asking a question, let alone answering one. Other times you'll won't get upvoted nor downvoted when you've actually contributed to the discussion. In these instances I lurk even when I ca…

Reddit's voting system has two issues:

(1) Lots of strategic downvoting. That's why no thread stays above 75%. It happens to comments as well as threads. Some of it is spammers trying to improve their own ranking, and some is probably just trolls.

(2) "Stalker" downvoting, which is when a person retaliates to a comment by downvoting that person's contributions en masse.

I wonder if they've put any machine learning muscle behind this. Is it easy to fix, or is it just a hard problem?

Re: Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"and you're more likely to have a good comment downvoted." This has never made sense to me. On some subreddits that focus on disciplines (like AskHistorians among many others), you can easily get downvoted (ie "dissapeared") just by asking a question, let alone answering one. Other times you'll won't get upvoted nor downvoted when you've actually contributed to the discussion. In these instances I lurk even when I ca…

Reddit's voting system has two issues: (1) Lots of strategic downvoting. That's why no thread stays above 75%. It happens to comments as well as threads. Some of it is spammers trying to improve their own ranking, and some is probably just trolls. (2) "Stalker" downvoting, which is when a person retaliates to a comment by downvoting that person's contributions en masse . I wonder if they've put any machine learning m…

I feel like (2) isn't difficult, in absolute terms, but is simply computationally expensive. Reddit is _still_ crashing all the time. They certainly don't have the resources to throw a bunch of machine learning or algorithmic muscle into preventing downvote spam.

Re: Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

#76
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can I get an invite, please? Email in profile. EDIT: Got it. Thanks. (So no one double-sends)

just sent invite..

could i have one? my email id is siamoreslr@gmail.com

Re: Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

#77
post #24

Very sad to see all the 'HN competitors' (lobsters, hackful, lamernews) are all essentially dead (at least extremely dormant). To me, all they needed were a small handful of dedicated posters/commenters (and to be open, i'm looking at you lobste.rs) to start to catch on; i'm very much reminded of the story of the reddit founders sockpuppeting to make the site not look like a ghost town; this kind of 'forced' activity…

I totally agree. It would even be easy to find old, well-received HN submissions that have likely been forgotten and to queue them up for resubmission to your new service.

Re: Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

#79
post #12

> has less negativity what do you mean by that? ironically I'll probably sound negative, but are you looking for a place which enforces PC to an ubearable point where the only accepted state is, you know, people standing in a circle smiling while performing a certain activity?

HN is definitely not the most supportive place on the internet. I've gotten some really good feedback from people who know what they're talking about, and read some discussion which was more interesting than the linked article. But then, I've also seen some people with a lot of karma who just bicker about insignificant things. Also, the fact that the community rules and best practices are ridiculously opaque, and every new person is initially viewed with hatred/mistrust for being 'from Reddit' or 'from /.' makes the place seem a bit hostile.

Re: Ask HN: A place like HN but with more nerdy stuff and less social stuff?

#80
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

on the topic, I dare ask for an invite to lobste.rs if someone has one lying around. I promise I won't be an ass. (Cause a week ago I reached the threshold of wanting to leave a comment enough times)

invite just sent..

Likewise, a spare invite would be appreciated. http://scr.im/amh
Post reply on HN