Live data from Hacker News

U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

reuters.com

71–80 of 193 posts

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#71
As a European center/moderate kind of person I agree with the US POTUS about this one thing: Iran can not be allowed to build nuclear weapons.

I personally don’t buy the line of thought that Iran has no such ambitions; YMMV.

Whether this war is effective at stopping that is another question.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#72
post #23

So what were they requesting $200 Billion for?

> So what were they requesting $200 Billion for?

That request was over a month ago and perhaps based on estimates using an operation tempo that was high. After the initial outburst, things may have slowed down.

That said, a lot of missiles were used, which, under current production rates, will take years to replenish: some 'extra' money may be needed to pay for production ramp up to get replacements sooner.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#74
post #34
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’d be okay with them forgiving student loans so long as they also pay me back for what I paid back. I think the best course is to allow students to default on their loans. With backed loans Unis know they’ll get their money one way or the other and keep ballooning their admin costs.

Why does improving things for future generations need to be held up until we can undo mistakes already done? The ladder got pulled up and some of us needed to scramble, but can't we lower the ladder back down for them anyway? We can do both. We can help people already saddled with debt, and also do things to prevent future generations from being saddled with debt in the first place. People who managed to climb out of…

Because we're still alive and also have a future and if the goal is to help people, there is no reason to draw the line at "paid it off already" when money is fungible and can still be used to secure a more comfortable future. Having paid off debts doesn't mean you climbed out of the hole, it means you did the responsible thing when you could have easily stashed the money away for your own retirement.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#75

The cost to operate the Federal government for one day is about $18 billion.

The only way you could arrive at such a high figure is if you included transfer payments like Social Security and Medicare in "the cost to run the government", which is not how most people understand "the cost to run the government".

Social security and Medicare account for 36% of the Federal budget and are absolutely understood as a cost to run the government. Calling them transfer payments doesn't obviate the fact that they are costs to American taxpayers. Social security and Medicare are also the two Federal outlays that economists fear will bankrupt the United States.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#78

Does this number include the cost of stockpile replenishment?

Stockpile/equipment costs are the bulk of what we've spent so far.

Operating a carrier group in a theatre is not that much more expensive than just maintaining an operational carrier group.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#79

For context Doge saved 2-3 billion by independent estimates. And cut some of the most important international aid around the world.

Other independent estimates say DOGE has cost America $135b. https://fortune.com/article/doge-mass-federal-workforce-cuts...

And spread death and disaster across the world, making chainsaw man musk the 21st century's bloodiest killer. https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/usaid-shutdown-has-led-to-hund...

But yes our politicians seem entirely unwilling to do anything about colossal expenditures on this "expedition", while all-too-willingly destroying American institutions. It's an insurrection of the elites; Federalist Society finally getting the destruction of the nation their treasonous tattered souls have lusted for. What a horror show they have us strapped in to.

Re: U.S. war in Iran has cost $25B so far, says Pentagon official

#80
post #71

As a European center/moderate kind of person I agree with the US POTUS about this one thing: Iran can not be allowed to build nuclear weapons. I personally don’t buy the line of thought that Iran has no such ambitions; YMMV. Whether this war is effective at stopping that is another question.

They had an agreement that was working which Trump tore up and then went to war on Israel’s behalf. So it was largely a solved problem until Trump created the problem.
Post reply on HN