Live data from Hacker News

Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

euronews.com

71–80 of 83 posts

Re: Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We have no wealth tax, no inheritance tax. If most of your income is a salary, the tax burden is high, but if you're living off investments, properties or generational funds, it's quite advantageous.

Sounds like in Sweden it's critical to pick the right parents.

Where is that not the case?

Re: Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don’t think it’s completely meaningless if you’re trying to save / invest. A smaller percentage of a larger salary is often more optimal than the reverse. This is why for example working in a high COL city with a high salary is ultimately better; your 10% going to savings will be higher. It might not matter if you never leave the high COL city, but ceteris paribus I’d rather have a larger number in the bank account…

>I don’t think it’s completely meaningless if you’re trying to save / invest It's largely meaningless, because some of what people are saving for in one country can be included in tax and social security contributions in another country - e.g. pensions and university tuition.

What do you think is more meaningful a metric?

Re: Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

#74
post #69

These numbers can get wonky fast. E.g. devs salaries in Ukraine are pegged to the dollar, so they get free raises as the exchange rates plummet. At the same time the cost of living in Ukraine was low before the war and only got lower. Oh and taxes are pretty low in Ukraine. So I'm pretty sure Ukranian devs will end up with one of the top salary rates in all of Ukraine, but the externalities of that are large.

>> free raises as the exchange rates plummet

Also developers use official exchange rate while everything is imported using market rate. 10% cut here.

>> the cost of living in Ukraine was low before the war and only got lower

This is not true. Some low skilled services are cheap, but high skilled are not.

Or are you talking about cost of housing near the frontline?

Dev salaries in Ukraine also down since the start of the war as no new projects are outsourced to the country.

Re: Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like in Sweden it's critical to pick the right parents.

Where is that not the case?

In countries lower in the ranking of wealth inequality, less so. I mean they are next to Russia, Saudi Arabia, and UAE. No, not everywhere it's the same.

Re: Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We have no wealth tax, no inheritance tax. If most of your income is a salary, the tax burden is high, but if you're living off investments, properties or generational funds, it's quite advantageous.

Sounds like in Sweden it's critical to pick the right parents.

That always helps. Another thing that helps is the free child care/school/university/health care/elderly care/parenting support/living support that the high taxes provides. The lowest standard is very high, the middle is comfy life but keep less dollars than if you lived in the states, the rich not-surprising gets away here too.

Re: Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

#77

Looking at salaries after tax is completely meaningless, what is even this article trying to infer. You have to take in to account the cost of living and also quality of services you get for it. France & Sweden is close in the numbers but France is notably cheaper to eat out and Healthcare quality can't even be compared (to French favor). But if you're wealthy you'd probably prefer Sweden still because of the low tax…

In addition (I'm European), I object to the use of per-hour wages instead of monthly salaries. It's less informative in Europe. Most jobs are full-time, salaries are typically advertised and talked about in monthly terms, and the length of the work week varies as well. Per month is just more useful as a comparison point. Oh and Sweden is slightly ahead of France on the latest EHCI. Sweden scores near the bottom on ac…

I am interested in learning more about EHCI? I found this link from 2018. It gave high scores to Switzerland and Northern Europe. France and Germany were the middle of the pack?

https://santesecu.public.lu/dam-assets/fr/publications/e/eur...

Re: Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Vacation is also never mentioned in those discussions or comparisons. 10 days in the US vs. 20-30 (+ 8-14 public holidays, depending on the state) in Germany is much more important for _me_ than the net income. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_annual_leave_b...

Can't you take days off without pay in the US? The numbers that usually come up are twice the income compared to France. Taking 20 more days off without pay means losing a month of salary, which doesn't come close to making up the difference.

Technically yes, but most employers do not look favorably on this route.

Re: Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

#79

I don't know whether this is AI slop or what. The first chart definitely doesn't show average salary AFTER tax, maybe it's a total cost to employer on hourly basis before any taxes or SSC. And the second chart titled "Where do taxes weigh the most on employers and employees?" doesn't actually show what it purports to show. It only shows a small slice of the social security contributions that employers pay. It shows:…

[dead]

Re: Which European countries have the best salaries after taxes?

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I don’t think it’s completely meaningless if you’re trying to save / invest It's largely meaningless, because some of what people are saving for in one country can be included in tax and social security contributions in another country - e.g. pensions and university tuition.

What do you think is more meaningful a metric?

Depends on what it is you really want to know. For macro economic comparisons you would probably want to use some metric that has "disposable income" in its name. And then you'd have to ask what this income includes. Does it include cash transfers? Transfers in kind (e.g. for health and education)? Does it use PPP or market exchange rates?

Here's a dataset that Eurostat publishes. It includes cash transfers and transfers in kind, compared using PPP (PPS) exchange rates:

Adjusted gross disposable income of households per capita in PPS

https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/view/tec00113/defa...

Post reply on HN