Live data from Hacker News

Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

fmn.dk

71–80 of 80 posts

Re: Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

#71
post #16
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Take it? You mean go to war with NATO over Greenland?

impossible, like war for Cyprus

A bit different, nether Russia nor China are NATO members like Turkey and Greece

Re: Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How would nuclear deterrence work for small entities like Denmark or Taiwan against huge entities like US or China? it only works at similar sizes

It made North Korea essentially invulnerable.

If absolutely necessary you could take them out in an preemptive strike. They have no second strike capabilities such as SLBMs.

It is still risky of course and not advisable.

Re: Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How would nuclear deterrence work for small entities like Denmark or Taiwan against huge entities like US or China? it only works at similar sizes

A nuclear deterrent is still a deterrent, no matter how small. No country (hopefully) wants to risk any kind of nuclear war. Ukraine would never have been invaded if it still had its nukes.

We cannot know. My best guess is that at some point in the future there will be a military conflict between two parties that have nukes. Pakistan vs India for instance. And although they have nukes they would fight conventionally unless one party is about to lose.

Re: Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

#74
post #6

This is the top post this morning? The issue won't come to military action. But if it did, Denmark could exercise all they want, and it would still last about ten minutes. Not sure how this is relevant to anything.

You're not sure how the potential for the US to go to war with an EU member state is relevant?

Re: Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

#75

Countries without a strong nuclear deterrence don't have a seat at the table in this new geopolitical era. Looking at you, Ukraine, Taiwan and (can't believe I'm saying this) Denmark.

There is a French tripwire force on the ground now as well. Denmark has allies.

[dead]

Re: Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A nuclear deterrent is still a deterrent, no matter how small. No country (hopefully) wants to risk any kind of nuclear war. Ukraine would never have been invaded if it still had its nukes.

We cannot know. My best guess is that at some point in the future there will be a military conflict between two parties that have nukes. Pakistan vs India for instance. And although they have nukes they would fight conventionally unless one party is about to lose.

> And although they have nukes they would fight conventionally unless one party is about to lose.

In every war, eventually, one side will be about to lose.

Re: Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

#77

Countries without a strong nuclear deterrence don't have a seat at the table in this new geopolitical era. Looking at you, Ukraine, Taiwan and (can't believe I'm saying this) Denmark.

How would nuclear deterrence work for small entities like Denmark or Taiwan against huge entities like US or China? it only works at similar sizes

> How would nuclear deterrence work for small entities like Denmark or Taiwan against huge entities like US or China? it only works at similar sizes

It works as long as the harm that can be threatened is sufficient to outweigh any perceived gain of winning. Small states may not be able to sustain as large of an arsenal, but they also rarely offer as much value to a victor.

Re: Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

#79
post #78
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a European (but not Danish), I feel like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription_in_Denmark is quite proactive.

how many months in Arctic training?

Nice try, Mr. Spy!

If I were to guess, probably all of the months (four to twelve) in units that are in the Arctic, and (very close to) zero months in other units. I also don't know how well military experience from other Danish regions translates to the Arctic. Probably quite well, I'd imagine.

Re: Danish Armed Forces expand their presence and continue exercises in Greenland

#80

What a waste of resources to have to defend against one of your closest allies. This is a country that went to war on behalf of the US in Afghanistan (and lost 44 souls doing so). Disrespectful and shameful.

Wow that seems really strange to me to bring up that body count as some sort of guilt trip mechanism in your criticism. But if we are going to play that game, how about we also list how many Danish and US soldiers died in Europe during WW2.
Post reply on HN