Live data from Hacker News

NASA announces unprecedented return of sick ISS astronaut and crew

livescience.com

71–80 of 151 posts

Re: NASA announces unprecedented return of sick ISS astronaut and crew

#71

It's great we can bring them down. What a terrifying experience to have a medical issue on the space station. Kidney stone? Ruptured appendix? intestinal blockage? How could you keep calm so far away!

it's only 250 miles

Maximum operating depth of a Nuclear submarine is 3,350 ft.

Re: NASA announces unprecedented return of sick ISS astronaut and crew

#72

It's great we can bring them down. What a terrifying experience to have a medical issue on the space station. Kidney stone? Ruptured appendix? intestinal blockage? How could you keep calm so far away!

[flagged]

The reason they are bringing the whole crew back is most likely cost related. The whole crew was due back in February anyway. They are bringing everyone home a bit early; otherwise they would need another flight a few weeks later.

And nobody is retreating: there will be 1 American and 2 Russians left on ISS. All of this from the article.

Re: NASA announces unprecedented return of sick ISS astronaut and crew

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Astronauts are of a breed apart. They're strapped onto a literally bomb which launches them into a vacuum, and windows where there is no chance of a mission abort. They've pretty much accepted a risk of death that most would simply not tolerate. Ex-military is common for astronauts for a reason.

Going on a spaceship is probably safer than driving a car.

Being an astronaut is about 50x more risky than riding in a car

Re: NASA announces unprecedented return of sick ISS astronaut and crew

#75
post #5

Why be so secretive? This is not a military mission. These missions cost a lot of taxpayer money (money well spend you may argue), but we deserve full transparency. You don't get to go to space on other people's money and expect privacy. We might want to learn from what went wrong here.

[deleted]

Re: NASA announces unprecedented return of sick ISS astronaut and crew

#76
post #15
post #5

Why be so secretive? This is not a military mission. These missions cost a lot of taxpayer money (money well spend you may argue), but we deserve full transparency. You don't get to go to space on other people's money and expect privacy. We might want to learn from what went wrong here.

The only medical condition I can think of which they would not disclose is pregnancy. That would lead to further questions and is controversial despite being very simple. Further evidenced by the fact that the affected crew member is unknown to the public.

That alone is enough reason to have a policy of never disclosing medical conditions.

Re: NASA announces unprecedented return of sick ISS astronaut and crew

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There have been a few instances, IIRC there was an Apollo mission that had a head cold spread among the whole crew. But that's unlikely to be the case here because they've been up there isolated for over 6 months now

Would it be possible for some food to have been contaminated with something? It seems unlikely.

this is what I'm thinking. GI related issues

Re: NASA announces unprecedented return of sick ISS astronaut and crew

#79
post #52

It's great we can bring them down. What a terrifying experience to have a medical issue on the space station. Kidney stone? Ruptured appendix? intestinal blockage? How could you keep calm so far away!

How could you keep calm so far away By going through a ten-year process that selects for calm people.

Somewhat related to this topic: https://youtube.com/watch?v=Zo62S0ulqhA
Post reply on HN