Live data from Hacker News

US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry

bbc.co.uk

71–80 of 304 posts

Re: US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry

#71
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My social media is full of rants about the ongoing trend of bringing fascism to the US and the authoritarian and repressive tendencies of the current president. Am I not allowed to say that?

You are allowed to say it. Unlike UK, you won’t be arrested. But you won’t be allowed in. Besides, why would you want to come if you don’t like it here?

Who is being arrested in the UK?

Re: US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry

#72
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My social media is full of rants about the ongoing trend of bringing fascism to the US and the authoritarian and repressive tendencies of the current president. Am I not allowed to say that?

You are allowed to say it. Unlike UK, you won’t be arrested. But you won’t be allowed in. Besides, why would you want to come if you don’t like it here?

> Besides, why would you want to come if you don’t like it here?

Family, work, others in the group who enjoy it, the level of enjoyment might still be above the level of frustration, wanting to help, emergencies, etc. I could think of many reasons one would want to go to a country even though you disagree with ~50% the population + current leaders.

I've been in North Korea as an example, but I'd never claim to support the ideas and politics of their leader(s).

Re: US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry

#74

Tying this into the Paul Krugman post about social media tech giants running the US [1], perhaps it's the US running the tech giants for mass surveilance? Especially of foreigners, of course. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46204100 Edit: Krugman

They have common interests.

Governments around the world criticise social media and tech giants but they still work with them because they want the concentration of power to enable surveillance.

Re: US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry

#76
post #34

[flagged]

On one hand, you are clearly exaggerating. On the other hand, the actual conversations I hear my friends having about business-trips to US are more stressed than conversation my dad used to have with my mom when he was traveling to do business for banks in India, Pakistan or Russia decade or two ago.

Where would the exaggeration be? In that they're not 'aryanising' corporations and hence it's not an apt comparison?

Re: US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry

#77
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My social media is full of rants about the ongoing trend of bringing fascism to the US and the authoritarian and repressive tendencies of the current president. Am I not allowed to say that?

You are allowed to say it. Unlike UK, you won’t be arrested. But you won’t be allowed in. Besides, why would you want to come if you don’t like it here?

There are plenty of things to like about America if you put aside the politics.

Personally I wouldn’t bother though. We were considering a trip to Florida next year but decided on France instead due to the widespread xenophobia.

Re: US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then they'll do a quick lookup to confirm if you actually don't have any accounts, and if they find any, they'll reject you because you lied. US agencies already are keeping track of what individuals have what online accounts, so they're asking to confirm, not to learn. If you truly don't have social media, their search won't show any hits, and there isn't much you can do about it. Just make sure you're actually answ…

How exactly are they going to link accounts with no real names, personal info or identifiable emails to a person?

Probably by the phone number used for account verification, in many cases

The anime avi posters will have to level up their OPSEC

Re: US could ask foreign tourists for five-year social media history before entry

#80
post #19

[flagged]

> Even here on Hacker News. It's just not discussed. US citizens are either championing MAGA or just acting like everything is normal or they're disinterested. Or their accounts were banned for being too contrarian, or they were systematically downvoted into invisibility.

HN won't even let me comment on the parent claim that US citizens are taking the situation passively. Which is horribly untrue. But the limit is a great example of a platform's rules (whether intentional or not) causing an important public perception.
Post reply on HN