Live data from Hacker News

Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

theconversation.com

71–80 of 166 posts

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#71
post #41

Sometimes I wonder if I’m using my phone, or if it’s using me. I know things like notifications and vibrations are designed to grab my attention, but the phone always seems to know exactly when I’m at my weakest. The moment I feel even a little bored or empty, my finger just taps open that familiar app before I even realize it. Have any of you found ways to break out of this cycle of being led around by your phone?

Yes and my comment is just relaying what professionals have to say about the phenomenon:

Bottom line up front: the way out is to set aside some time for a menial task that isn't mentally taxing.

Screens are a particularly effective means of avoiding processing one's emotions. Those, of course, don't go away by themselves so if you don't take time to deal with them, you create a dependency.

The moment before going to sleep is typically when piled up emotions and intrusive thoughts return, so that's also when the temptation to set them aside is the greatest.

Resisting that temptation, but giving in to it eventually is dangerous, because next time the signal is stronger.

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#72
I don't understand how having faceid, a touchscreen, vibration, gps would manipulate my emotions.

Makes no sense.

Developers using these features to build app that makes you addicted ? Yes. But these features in itself are not manipulatives or triggering reflexes.

I just don't understand the author reasoning...

I don't use addictive social media on my phone and when I receive notification, my phone makes a sound, it vibrates and yet I don't feel urged to look at it.

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#73
post #5

Bo Burnham put it succinctly, although he was talking about children on apps: "When they go to sleep at night, they have to choose between all of the information ever published in the history of the world, or the back of their eyelids." The smartphone is a perverted implementation of the goal that people use to fantasize about back in the early days of the computer revolution: a personal terminal to the world of audi…

> When they go to sleep at night, they have to choose between all of the information ever published in the history of the world, or the back of their eyelids

They are not tired enough if they choose to use their smartphone, that's an education issue.

Children are taught the value of a good night of sleep, they are taught by having fulfilling daily lives and exhausting. If you let them be like a plant, yeah they will be just as dumb as a plant.

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#74

I don't understand how having faceid, a touchscreen, vibration, gps would manipulate my emotions. Makes no sense. Developers using these features to build app that makes you addicted ? Yes. But these features in itself are not manipulatives or triggering reflexes. I just don't understand the author reasoning... I don't use addictive social media on my phone and when I receive notification, my phone makes a sound, it…

I actively dislike my phone. It's an entirely to expensive platform that I "need" to own, to interact with certain parts of society. The screen is to small to be useful for media consumption, without making me sick. It's also to small to be useful as a web browser, except in an emergency.

It is great to have GPS and mobile payments, and Uber if you're in the US as it's pretty much impossible to locate a regular taxi. Other than that it's ... for making phone calls, texting is done better view a desktop app, though I need the smartphone to activate the account (Signal).

Claiming that the phone is manipulating is a bit of a stretch. One roundabout why I can see the phone manufacturers being complicit is in pushing what a phone can and should do. If you remove the manipulating apps, then you end up with people replacing their phone way less frequently. E.g. the iPhone 7 is still a good phone, it has texting (and iMessage or Signal), calling, security updates, notes and updated maps. It probably sucks at running Instagram and TikTok (though I'd assume it plays videos just fine). Apple just isn't really going to make a ton of that original sale anymore.

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#75
> sharing biometric data through pre-loaded health and wellness apps.

I've been thinking about finally getting a smartwatch to keep tabs on my sleep and encourage me to do more exercise, like jogging for a certain amount of time or something. Suggestions for privacy respecting, ideally FOSS solutions?

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#76
post #75

> sharing biometric data through pre-loaded health and wellness apps. I've been thinking about finally getting a smartwatch to keep tabs on my sleep and encourage me to do more exercise, like jogging for a certain amount of time or something. Suggestions for privacy respecting, ideally FOSS solutions?

One thing to keep in mind is that studies that evaluate the sleep tracking of smartwatches and smartphones typically show them to be wildly inaccurate, to the point of being useless

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#77
I've switched to a CAT S22 Android builder's flip phone, and my usage has dropped significantly. The screen is so small and fiddly that it makes me feel sick using it for extended periods - exactly what you want from an adictive substance like a smart phone. Having to physically open it to use it, and then waiting 5 seconds before it lights up, creates a psychic barrier to just 'quickly checking for updates'. The camera is like an early 2000s cheap digicam - just about good enough for documenting things but it hardly beckons you to want to photograph your life constantly for social media. It's a PITA to use and that's why it's perfect for everyday use.

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#78
post #75

> sharing biometric data through pre-loaded health and wellness apps. I've been thinking about finally getting a smartwatch to keep tabs on my sleep and encourage me to do more exercise, like jogging for a certain amount of time or something. Suggestions for privacy respecting, ideally FOSS solutions?

For iPhone there's Out-Run [0] which is a great open source running app with no vendor tracking (it optionally tracks your runs locally).

For exercise, I would kindly suggest you don't make things over complicated. There's no tech solution that prevents you from putting on a pair of running shoes, getting outside and finding out what does and doesn't work yourself.

[0] https://apps.apple.com/gb/app/out-run/id1477511092

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#79
This is getting ridiculous

Everything we interact with has an emotional impact. And smart phones trigger our reflexes because they are literally tools for communication.

> Most of these features were developed decades ago for other uses. GPS was created by the U.S. military in the early 1970s, then was adopted by hikers and sailors to both navigate and to allow others to locate them if necessary.

> Vibration alerts were created for pagers in the late 1970s for professionals — from hospital staff to travelling salespeople — to notify them of an important phone call.

> Sound alerts became more widespread with Tamagotchi and other 1990s digital pets. Those toys are especially significant when discussing today’s psychological dependency on portable devices.

Seriously???

Re: Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes

#80
post #75

> sharing biometric data through pre-loaded health and wellness apps. I've been thinking about finally getting a smartwatch to keep tabs on my sleep and encourage me to do more exercise, like jogging for a certain amount of time or something. Suggestions for privacy respecting, ideally FOSS solutions?

> I've been thinking about finally getting a smartwatch to keep tabs on my sleep and encourage me to do more exercise, like jogging for a certain amount of time or something.

Do people really need watches to able to sleep normally or get some exercise?

Post reply on HN