Live data from Hacker News

Twake Drive – An open-source alternative to Google Drive

github.com

71–80 of 219 posts

Re: Twake Drive – An open-source alternative to Google Drive

#71
post #61

As others have asked, how does it compare with nextCloud ownCloud? And does it have native clients for the usual suspects? Windows/Mac/Mobile...

IME NextCloud is a bloated PHP monster with poor performance. Twake seems to be leaner and have a narrower scope.

[deleted]

Re: Twake Drive – An open-source alternative to Google Drive

#72

As others have asked, how does it compare with nextCloud ownCloud? And does it have native clients for the usual suspects? Windows/Mac/Mobile...

I tried to install nextcloud once, and it was an exercise in misery.

If you just need a web interface to your filesystem, there’s this single Go executable (https://github.com/filebrowser/filebrowser) that supports sharing and minimal user management.

Re: Twake Drive – An open-source alternative to Google Drive

#76
I built something similar years ago. These are terribly hard to build, so I did a bit of digging.

1: This appears to be backed by a French company called Linagoria. I don't know much about the company, but they've been around for a bit.

2: I experimented with Mongodb for the similar product, and it turned out to be very unreliable. A lot can change since I used Mongodb, but in general, I'm weary of any product that uses it unless there's an expectation that data is lossy.

(Which was the problem Mongodb had at the time: Their CTO only wanted to target lossy data use cases, but the people interested in using Mondodb wanted a database that was easier to use than SQL.)

Re: Twake Drive – An open-source alternative to Google Drive

#77
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I do, password-protected of course. It is the only "native" way I found to get server files access to my iPhone without downloading a third party app (via Files).

I really hope you lock it down to something like Tailscale so that you have a private area network and your Samba share isn’t open to the entire world. Samba is a complicated piece of software built around protocols from the 90s. It’s designed around the old idea of physical network security where it’s isolated on a LAN and has a long long history of serious critical security vulnerabilities (eg here’s an RCE from th…

It seems like every network filesystem is irredeemably terrible. SMB and NFS the stuff of security nightmares, chatty performance issues, and awkward user id mapping. WebDAV is a joke. SSHFS is slow. You can get really crazy with CephFS or GlusterFS, and for all that complexity, you don't get much farther way from SMB/NFS issues with those either.

My solution: Share nothing and use rsync.

Re: Twake Drive – An open-source alternative to Google Drive

#80
Open source drive tools live or die on three things. 1) Simple sync that never surprises. 2) Clean conflict handling you can explain to a non tech friend. 3) And zero drama upgrades.

If Twake nails those and keeps a sane on prem story with S3 and LDAP, it has a shot. The harder part is trust and docs. Clear threat model. Crisp migration guides from Drive and Dropbox. And a tiny CLI that just works on a headless box. Do these and teams will try it for real work, not just weekend tests.

Post reply on HN