Live data from Hacker News

Find SF parking cops

walzr.com

71–80 of 498 posts

Re: Find SF parking cops

#72
post #36

I'd be interested in a "loserboard", i.e. who consistently writes the fewest tickets.

The loserboard I'd be interested in is which license plates consistently receive the most tickets.

I'd guess the top spots are just super wealthy people who figure that at their "hourly rate", paying for parking is basically more costly than just eating the tickets. Like if someone's time is worth $10k+/hour, the parking tickets are basically just premium parking fees that are still "cheaper" than spending even a minute dealing with payment... Let your assistant pay whatever tickets you get in the mail instead.

Re: Find SF parking cops

#73
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

> So is tax evasion No. “In the United States, tax evasion constitutes a crime” [1]. [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/tax_evasion

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/6663

Moreover: https://www.irs.gov/irm/part25/irm_25-001-006

Re: Find SF parking cops

#74
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Traffic tickets are typically civil, not criminal.

[flagged]

You're not afraid to admit what's marketed as a fine or deterrent is simply a weirdly targeted tax but you're annoyed that it's sometimes avoidable due to only sporadic assessment of it.

IDK what plane this policy spectrum exists on but man is horseshoe theory clearly alive and well on it.

Re: Find SF parking cops

#75

I did a fascinating analysis of SFMTA data a few years back. They posted a public list of names and license plates [1] that they refuse to take down, despite many emails from me over the years. I found a particular license plate that belonged to a plumber with an impeccable 5 star reputation on Yelp, whose business in SF was effectively ended by street sweeping fines. He accidentally paid the same ticket twice, which…

Reading this comment I’m stumped as to what SF can learn from this. There’s a lesson in there somewhere but I have no idea what it could be.

Oh well.

https://m.youtube.com/shorts/fBoqMMPoU9k

Re: Find SF parking cops

#76

Incredible work. I'm disappointed to see so many of the leaderboard items are street cleaning tickets. I get it - street cleaning are "easy" tickets to write in bulk, and therefore efficient ROI for PCO time, but they're not the most important violations to cite compared to safety-critical things like blocked bike lanes (which SFMTA has an official policy to completely ignore citizen reports thereof), double-parking,…

>Incredible work. I'm disappointed to see so many of the leaderboard items are street cleaning tickets.

Why wouldn't it be? It's basically spawn camping or deer baiting or shooting fish in a barrel or whatever analogy you want to use.

Re: Find SF parking cops

#77
post #49

It would be great to see more automatic payment and enforcement. It's great that buses can issue tickets for blocking bus lanes, but I would absolutely love for their to be more automatic enforcement of blocking bike lanes and meter violations. I'm not in SF a lot these days, but I have noticed some particularly fancy parking meters that at least have tap-to-pay and might have more. Instead of a ticket, you should ju…

Is it illegal to block bike lanes in SF? I ask because it is not illegal to do so in California, according to the learner's permit test my daughter recently took.

The DMV is unfortunately wrong about this, with an invalid interpretation of CVC - the DMV handbook is NOT the law (it's a simplistic layman's interpretation), and is not a valid legal defense.

That said, in SF proper it's absolutely inarguably illegal as a violation called "Obstructing traffic" in the SF transportation code. A bike lane is an active travel lane for vehicles as defined under the CVC (including bicycles), and therefore stopping in one is illegal just like stopping in a car lane. I've had drivers cited for this in the past.

Re: Find SF parking cops

#78

Incredible work. I'm disappointed to see so many of the leaderboard items are street cleaning tickets. I get it - street cleaning are "easy" tickets to write in bulk, and therefore efficient ROI for PCO time, but they're not the most important violations to cite compared to safety-critical things like blocked bike lanes (which SFMTA has an official policy to completely ignore citizen reports thereof), double-parking,…

On principle, I agree.

In practice, delivery vehicles don't have a place to safely stop, because that space is allocated to free street parking for private vehicles.

Subsidized street parking for cars are externalizing their costs onto UPS/Fedex/Amazon, etc. who are then passing that cost along to the safety of the public.

Re: Find SF parking cops

#79
What's funny is secure IDs could have easily prevented this but, even if the city discovers it and wants to shut it down now, I'd bet actually fixing the system would be too costly (IDs tend to couple to everything).

Re: Find SF parking cops

#80
post #41

What would really be incredible would be if the city made this kind of data public intentionally.

They do! There's a data set, updated daily: https://data.sfgov.org/Transportation/SFMTA-Parking-Citation... It currently has 22 million parking tickets dating back to 2008.

Incredible!
Post reply on HN