Live data from Hacker News

Sign in with Google in Chrome

underpassapp.com

71–80 of 313 posts

Re: Sign in with Google in Chrome

#71
post #12

Does nobody find this intrusive when it appears on sites like pornhub? Of all places where I'd sign in with a Google account... holy heck, I was very surprised they chose to let Google do that nearly-fullscreen popup on their site upon every visit (since you visit in private tab, it's a fresh session every time) Even on reddit it annoys the heck out of me and I was very surprised they let this third party ruin the ex…

Try visiting pornhub from Texas :)

Re: Sign in with Google in Chrome

#73
post #33
post #21

The Chrome experience is actually part of a new standard, Federated Credential Management (or FedCM for short). The idea is to create a browser mediated login experience that gives the identity provider and web app what they need without being able to correlate requests across the Internet. I am working on an article on this topic. If you are interested in learning more, here's a video from a recent auth focused conf…

Can we block sharing email addresses by default? It seems every time I sign in with Google the site / app starts SPAMming me without my consent. It's pretty much why I don't use it: The SPAM.

My gmail is quite old and well used, and it gets relatively little spam. I go through and aggressively unsubscribe link everything I don't want to see, and it surprisingly works. I get more spam on my @myname.tld address than my gmail even and I keep that one quieter.

Almost every site actually does unsubscribe, and those that don't get marked as junk.

Re: Sign in with Google in Chrome

#75
It's not just a Google annoyance, these types of things are all over the web. I have uBlock Origin settings to limit these types of things, like others in this thread have explained.

But there's a bigger issue with the modern web. Here's my message to any web developer, company, organization, anyone who has control over content on the public web: if I visit your page and I have to click away something in order to do what I came to do, you have failed miserably.

Re: Sign in with Google in Chrome

#76
post #12

Does nobody find this intrusive when it appears on sites like pornhub? Of all places where I'd sign in with a Google account... holy heck, I was very surprised they chose to let Google do that nearly-fullscreen popup on their site upon every visit (since you visit in private tab, it's a fresh session every time) Even on reddit it annoys the heck out of me and I was very surprised they let this third party ruin the ex…

There's a big upside to Google One Tap. It makes users sign up for your product like crazy. I recently added it to a SaaS web app I'm working on, and the number of new sign ups went up 8x overnight. You don't necessarily have to create an account to use the minimal functionalty of our app, but after signing up you do get some perks, and we get a way to communicate with the user through email. So I think it can be ben…

Big upside to the provider, not necessarily the consumer.

Perplexity has a "sign in with Google" pop up that loads late, often when I've already started typing in my query, and thus blocks the rest of my typing, negatively affecting the UX of the service. So I looked up how to get the fuck rid of it and added that method to uBlock Origin, and now I'm a happy (freeloading) chappy.

Re: Sign in with Google in Chrome

#77
post #12

Does nobody find this intrusive when it appears on sites like pornhub? Of all places where I'd sign in with a Google account... holy heck, I was very surprised they chose to let Google do that nearly-fullscreen popup on their site upon every visit (since you visit in private tab, it's a fresh session every time) Even on reddit it annoys the heck out of me and I was very surprised they let this third party ruin the ex…

There's a big upside to Google One Tap. It makes users sign up for your product like crazy. I recently added it to a SaaS web app I'm working on, and the number of new sign ups went up 8x overnight. You don't necessarily have to create an account to use the minimal functionalty of our app, but after signing up you do get some perks, and we get a way to communicate with the user through email. So I think it can be ben…

> Beneficial to both parties

Ah yes, because who doesn’t want more emails from a sites they’ve visited one time

Re: Sign in with Google in Chrome

#78
Kinda related to this: I _really_ wish that SSO providers would be better about telling me when my account was already used to log into a service. When I hit "sign in with Google", see my 4 accounts, and have to guess which one I used to sign into the service...

Maybe I'm missing some security detail here

Re: Sign in with Google in Chrome

#79
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A generic way to stop this across all devices would be great. I don't suppose something can be done with DNS via Pi-hole?

You could block account.google.com (or google.com) if you don’t use any google services or expect anyone on your network to use any google services*. * I think search still works without an account, but I don’t think anything else works that way these days. The last I know was YouTube and I get a “sign in to confirm your age” on YouTube on most videos I try to watch without being logged in.

As much as I'd love to do that, it might be a bridge too far...

Re: Sign in with Google in Chrome

#80
post #78

Kinda related to this: I _really_ wish that SSO providers would be better about telling me when my account was already used to log into a service. When I hit "sign in with Google", see my 4 accounts, and have to guess which one I used to sign into the service... Maybe I'm missing some security detail here

The problem is that at that point in the flow, it's owned by the SSO provider. The SSO provider can't know with certainty what account has an active account with the website.
Post reply on HN