Live data from Hacker News

Sortfolio lives

37signals.com

71–75 of 75 posts

Re: Sortfolio lives

#71
post #59
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You have no idea? You launched wild accusations that we were just playing everyone with our proposal and that we actually just had a buyer all along. If we had a buyer at $480K, we would not have bothered listing it again. We would just have sold it. I think the only reason why you consider my attitude an outlier is because I state it. Every business have a cut off point where a potential return is not worth the hass…

"wild accusations that we were just playing everyone" You are 100% incorrect as to what I actually did and why. In business what I had suggested as a possibility is not something that would be frowned upon at all. It's the way business is done quite frequently. Do you think games aren't played in business and especially in negotiation? Consequently I wasn't being critical at all according to the way I viewed what you…

Err, I think what he means is that you implied that 37Signals was lying, that they pretended not to have a buyer, and to be considering shuttering the site, when in fact they knew that they had a buyer. I can only speak for myself, but if that were proven, I would certainly frown upon it.

I think a lot of 37Signals' brand, and a lot of its relationship with its audience, comes from their transparency and straightforwardness. I think that context also adds to the sensitivity. If it came out that they were lying to the public, it would be detrimental to them for sure.

Not saying DHH answered in the best way possible, or that you did anything "wrong," but you are squirming around the fact that you speculated publicly about them doing something untoward.

Re: Sortfolio lives

#72
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And DHH is not exactly known for his tact.

If I was being called out as a liar after being very public about a business deal, I would lose my sense of tact also. Seriously, how much of the hate is from folks that will never have this opportunity, wouldn't do it the same way even if they did, and just want to complain?

All of it.

Re: Sortfolio lives

#74

Does anyone have an explanation why it wasn't possible to sell Sortfolio when it was more popular, but suddenly at the deadline the deal materialized at the price that it was announced long time ago? According to Compete.com, in the last 12 months Sortfolio traffic decreased more than 75% (4 times): http://siteanalytics.compete.com/sortfolio.com/

Same reason so many people are at the post office at midnight on April 15th filing their tax returns.

Deadlines work.

Re: Sortfolio lives

#75
post #48
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At grave risk of sounding even more patronizing than I usually do, let me try to help you with something: HN people spend a lot of time arguing with each other, often about nonsense or trivia (hey, myself included). In those arguments, it is very normal to say "I have trouble believing X is true" or "I have a hard time believing Y". And while it's not the most polite way to express disagreement, it's more annoying th…

Thanks for your comment. Honestly, I just wrote what I had on my mind that moment, without much meta-thinking. You are probably right, in hindsight should at least have phrased it less direct. However, without disregarding your concern: Should I refrain from posting at all when what I have to say boils down to "I don't believe your story"? Would you also have reacted to a politely phrased comment saying the same thin…

> Should I refrain from posting at all when what I have to say boils down to "I don't believe your story"?

Yes, that's exactly what you should. That sort of comment contributes exactly nothing to the discussion.

Post reply on HN