Live data from Hacker News

Ants learned to farm fungi during a mass extinction

arstechnica.com

71–73 of 73 posts

Re: Ants learned to farm fungi during a mass extinction

#71
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not the clade of 'terrible lizards'. Paleontology accepts the cladistic view and so should a popular science article.

The clade has been expanded well beyond its literal, historic, or popular understanding. Which is why the popular science article is confused, because the articles point is actually more correct from a popular point of view, while being at odds with the technical (but weird) newer definition. Because the ‘terrible lizards’ DID go extinct at the end of the Cretaceous, and what ended up evolving from their not really t…

If someone asked for a dinosaur fossil and you showed them a small winged thing embedded in a rock they likely would be confused too. Wind the clock back 65 million years to before the Cretaceous extinction event. The first bird like dinos appear in the Jurassic, ~100 millions year before the extinction. The time of the dinosaurs was full of small and large dinos adapted to all sorts of niches. In the end the flying therapods were the survivors.

We clearly have different view points, but I've enjoyed the discussion.

Re: Ants learned to farm fungi during a mass extinction

#72
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The clade has been expanded well beyond its literal, historic, or popular understanding. Which is why the popular science article is confused, because the articles point is actually more correct from a popular point of view, while being at odds with the technical (but weird) newer definition. Because the ‘terrible lizards’ DID go extinct at the end of the Cretaceous, and what ended up evolving from their not really t…

If someone asked for a dinosaur fossil and you showed them a small winged thing embedded in a rock they likely would be confused too. Wind the clock back 65 million years to before the Cretaceous extinction event. The first bird like dinos appear in the Jurassic, ~100 millions year before the extinction. The time of the dinosaurs was full of small and large dinos adapted to all sorts of niches. In the end the flying…

I think we’re actually both in agreement, actually.

Re: Ants learned to farm fungi during a mass extinction

#73
post #17
post #16

Yet another science piece that perpetuates the misconception that “the mass extinction killed the dinosaurs”. The clade of dinosaurs is not extinct and it bothers me that science writers don't seem to learn this fact and keep getting it wrong.

Yet another comment saying someone is wrong with no context or links for the rest of us. :(

My apologies. I will provide links next time. For now, my sibling comment will do the trick. Birds are dinosaurs, so dinosaurs are not extinct.
Post reply on HN