Live data from Hacker News

Instagram Recommends Sexual Videos to Accounts for 13-Year-Olds, Tests Show

wsj.com

71–80 of 109 posts

Re: Instagram Recommends Sexual Videos to Accounts for 13-Year-Olds, Tests Show

#71
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The reason for the US government banning TikTok is not that TikTok is a worse product (it is superior). The reason is that it is a massive geopolitical risk. People often conflate these two.

Insta/FB/X/TikTok are all massive geo-political risks for a large number of countries. They have been called many times as tools for social engineering against governments. There is no good side in this debate.

Correct, this is why Insta/FB/X are banned in China.

Re: Instagram Recommends Sexual Videos to Accounts for 13-Year-Olds, Tests Show

#72
post #47
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess but I had unfiltered access to the internet starting around this age and it was fine. There were two stages of my life, too young to understand or have any desire for sexual content, and old enough to want and seek out sexual content. At 13 I was well into the second stage and it's super weird how we pretend that tweens and teens aren't horny as hell despite all of us having lived through the hormonal onslaug…

Sure, but go to one of the main porn websites and you're shown extremely hardcore content on the front page, in video thumbnails. Often there's something "rough", probaby something about step siblings, and in most cases the actors are being exploited or quite possibly trafficked. I agree with your sentiment though. Removing access to pornographic material isn't the answer. But these days unfiltered access comes with…

You have a point, but my guess is it's simply a numbers game. I remember everyone in middle school sharing explicit, gore, "rough" LiveLeak vides in our school-wide MSN group chats. Probably a percentage of people suffered because of it later in life, but at that point still not everyone was connected to the Internet. Even if the percentage of people that get negatively affected stays the same nowadays, the absolute numbers are bigger, so it makes it to the headlines more often.

Re: Instagram Recommends Sexual Videos to Accounts for 13-Year-Olds, Tests Show

#73
post #9

> In one clip that Instagram recommended to a test account identified as 13 years old, an adult performer promised to send a picture of her “chest bags” via direct message to anyone who commented on her video. Another flashed her genitalia at the camera. When it comes encryption and privacy the legislators just can't wait to jump in an "save the children", let's see how vigorous they are going to be investigating and…

It’s almost as if it’s not a single factor issue and insta could stand to improve its under-age content filters AND TikTok can also be a threat because of its ties to China.

Re: Instagram Recommends Sexual Videos to Accounts for 13-Year-Olds, Tests Show

#74
post #9

> In one clip that Instagram recommended to a test account identified as 13 years old, an adult performer promised to send a picture of her “chest bags” via direct message to anyone who commented on her video. Another flashed her genitalia at the camera. When it comes encryption and privacy the legislators just can't wait to jump in an "save the children", let's see how vigorous they are going to be investigating and…

[deleted]

Re: Instagram Recommends Sexual Videos to Accounts for 13-Year-Olds, Tests Show

#75

I'm genuinely curious, how old were you when you were first exposed to sexual content? I think I was like 7 or 8. Like, we had a channel ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RTV_Palma ) publicly broadcasting porn after midnight (I don't remember watching that) and all the older (~15YO) kids around the neighborhood were collecting porn magazines from who knows where and hiding them around in "caches". I remember all the ol…

[deleted]

Re: Instagram Recommends Sexual Videos to Accounts for 13-Year-Olds, Tests Show

#78
post #61

I wonder if whoever ran this test prefers this type of content and its tied to a wifi network, same device, linked account, IP or location and there's no detail of the setting of the test. Too many factors going on to conclude with not a lot of transparency for reproducibility or flaws in the data collection.

Ah yes, too complex to really understand what's going on so we will hand wave it away.

It should be a hard rule that people under a certain age CAN NOT have this kind of content recommended, there should be precisely 0 ways for the algorithm to promote sexual material to children.

Re: Instagram Recommends Sexual Videos to Accounts for 13-Year-Olds, Tests Show

#79
post #61

I wonder if whoever ran this test prefers this type of content and its tied to a wifi network, same device, linked account, IP or location and there's no detail of the setting of the test. Too many factors going on to conclude with not a lot of transparency for reproducibility or flaws in the data collection.

It doesn’t matter. The account was marked with an age. IG pushed sexual content to it.

You can add as much other information to the picture as you want, but that’s the black and white issue.

Besides, how often do 13yo’s have their own wifi and IP address?

Re: Instagram Recommends Sexual Videos to Accounts for 13-Year-Olds, Tests Show

#80
post #65

I know this sounds defeatist but, I don't know why anyone even bothers to report things like this anymore. Meta doing something they're not supposed to do, even after promising they'd never do it again? This isn't news. This is a Thursday. Our governments aren't going to do anything about it. We all know it. In part because not enough constituents are complaining loudly enough (or, you know; at all) about these compa…

If this is the innovation we get from Section 230, then we need carve outs.
Post reply on HN