Live data from Hacker News

YouTube experimenting with server-side ad injection

fosstodon.org

71–80 of 95 posts

Re: YouTube experimenting with server-side ad injection

#71
post #40
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or the ~100% of users who wouldn't understand anything you just wrote will shell out for a premium subscription.

Users don't need to understand an ad blocker to use it either, do they? That said, the predictable next step would just be for Google to turn on DRM on Youtube videos.

[deleted]

Re: YouTube experimenting with server-side ad injection

#72
post #40
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or the ~100% of users who wouldn't understand anything you just wrote will shell out for a premium subscription.

Users don't need to understand an ad blocker to use it either, do they? That said, the predictable next step would just be for Google to turn on DRM on Youtube videos.

[dead]

Re: YouTube experimenting with server-side ad injection

#73
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I got one that straight up told me my penis was too small to please my partner. I have to say that you'd think the supposed best and brightest that FAANG companies hire could come up with a bit more of a sophisticated pitch than "your peepee is too small".

Amazon Prime Video is not much better. We recently got an ad for an all black dating site. I’d expect them to guess our ethnicity a bit better (and the content was as 1950’s cracker white as can be), but ignoring that, they were literally selling us diapers a while back, and the kids have their own video profile. Based on our purchases, it’s not physiologically plausible that only one adult lives in the house. Given…

someone is watching porn, and of a particular variety, me thinks.

Re: YouTube experimenting with server-side ad injection

#75
post #40
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or the ~100% of users who wouldn't understand anything you just wrote will shell out for a premium subscription.

Users don't need to understand an ad blocker to use it either, do they? That said, the predictable next step would just be for Google to turn on DRM on Youtube videos.

if this (ad injection) goes in and becomes a standard - could they argue it is their form of drm and try to take down sponsorblock with dmca crap?

Re: YouTube experimenting with server-side ad injection

#76
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’d like to say that I don’t mind YouTube ads but I actually do much of the time because they try to sell me on an investment scam, some tactical doomsday merch, or fundamentalist religion depending on the theme of the video. Many YouTube ads truly feel adversarial and it is hard to not mind that.

I got one that straight up told me my penis was too small to please my partner. I have to say that you'd think the supposed best and brightest that FAANG companies hire could come up with a bit more of a sophisticated pitch than "your peepee is too small".

Sure but I don't think the companies buying ad time on YT are generally FAANG.

Re: YouTube experimenting with server-side ad injection

#78
post #42

Not only are the ads annoyingly long and frequent sometimes, and not only does the ridiculously expensive YouTube TV subscription I still haven't talked my family out of not prevent ads on YouTube, but the _way_ it does ads is incredibly annoying: it's easy enough to click the "Skip" button once it shows up if you're sitting in front of your computer or watching on your phone, but it's really hard to do when your han…

In germany a consumer protection organisation currently sues Facebook because of the difference between the stalkerads and the adfree options. Companies buy add for cents and to be adfree you have to pay 10€ per month and they don't think that an average user sees thousands of ads each month.

Re: YouTube experimenting with server-side ad injection

#79

I find the baked-in ads in my parents VHS tapes to be quaint and informative. I don't feel that way about current YouTube ads!

Some were really good: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qDO6iNafSek

the irony of submitting a YT link

Re: YouTube experimenting with server-side ad injection

#80

I have to wonder if they never have due to fear that people will stop using the platform. I honestly will stop using it. I don't mind ads, but they always come on YouTube at the worst time, if you're watching something informative, they cut your brain off from that into some obscure that has no relevancy to your life.

Why would they fear people who adblock leaving the platform?
Post reply on HN