Live data from Hacker News

FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data

docs.fcc.gov

71–80 of 202 posts

Re: FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data

#71
post #2

How much is the cost per user? Maybe it is not that much in the end (as usual)

The total fine seems to be $200M, so maybe a buck a person. That’s still a whole lot more than their previous fine of $0.00 for it. Now we have a precedent.

>That’s still a whole lot more than their previous fine of $0.00

No, it's barely more.

Re: FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data

#72
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel that up to a point the fines do little in the grand scheme of things, as they will pass the expense of the fines on to us, the consumer.

Since Corporations are people, revoke their corporate charter for a couple years while they "do time" to pay for their criminal behavior.

If they are people, do three strike laws apply to them?

Re: FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data

#73

> "sharing access to customers’ location information without consent..." I'm not seeing anything here preventing the carriers from just adding "sharing location data" to the EULA / privacy policy that no one reads and continuing on - now with "consent". Without a requirement to offer a separate opt-out, this just seems like a temporary road bump that changes nothing in the long run.

I would like to see laws addressing the issue itself, e.g. banning any collection of location data unless it's explicitly needed and used by the collecting agent/service themselves, and banning sharing/selling it.

Re: FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data

#74
post #18
post #9

Sprint - $12 million fine (In 2019, Sprint Corporation's revenue amounted to 33.6 billion U.S. dollars) T-Mobile – $80 million fine (T-Mobile US annual revenue for 2021 was $80.118B) AT&T - $57 million fine (AT&T revenue for the twelve months ending March 31, 2024 was $122.317B) Verizon - $47 million fine (Verizon annual revenue for 2023 was $133.974B)

Sprint - 0.0003 of revenue T-Mobile - 0.0009 of revenue AT&T - 0.0004 of revenue Verizon - 0.0003 of revenue

Makes a speeding ticket for someone making minimum wage look expensive

Re: FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data

#75
post #54

why don't they fine them for delivering spam? like $1 per instance or something motivating?

What does that have to do with selling data?

the point is they fine spammers supposedly and nothing changes; i wasn't clear.

Re: FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data

#76

Did they ever fine anyone over AT&T letting NSA tap into all decrypted network data, cause that seems a lot more egregious lol. https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/25/nsa-att-intercept-surveill...

The NSA could be self-funding if they simply charged people for the restoration of backups they made of everyones' drives.

Re: FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data

#77

The core issue is transparency. I don't want to see a 'privacy policy', I want to see who a company has sold/given my information to and what limitations that sale has. The concept is simple. If you collect anything about me and allow some other entity access, you tell me about it/make it easy for me to see -and- block. Most of this abuse of personal data would go away if people knew it was going on.

The core issue isn’t transparency. It’s surveillance and powerlessness

Re: FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data

#80
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sprint - 0.0003 of revenue T-Mobile - 0.0009 of revenue AT&T - 0.0004 of revenue Verizon - 0.0003 of revenue

Makes a speeding ticket for someone making minimum wage look expensive

Look expensive? It means not eating
Post reply on HN