Live data from Hacker News

Finding lead in Stanley's Quencher

lumafield.com

71–74 of 74 posts

Re: Finding lead in Stanley's Quencher

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So you want me to remove all the lead/tin solder from the stuff I'm repairing... and do WHAT with it, exactly? I've been using the same roll of Kestler fine solder since the I got it about 20 years ago at the Dayton hamfest. I'm not exactly a bulk distributor of the stuff. The ad-hominem attacks are un-called for. I was merely pointing out that the other used of lead involved boiling them off... and thus the lead was…

"20 years ago at the Dayton hamfest". yeah explains a lot. There is a lot animosity from older gen EEs towards lead free solder, lot of lies as the flux is more poisonous etc., however the point is in fact is not only personal harm, but reduction of consumption of lead at first place. The less lead is produced and thrown away the better.

[deleted]

Re: Finding lead in Stanley's Quencher

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So you want me to remove all the lead/tin solder from the stuff I'm repairing... and do WHAT with it, exactly? I've been using the same roll of Kestler fine solder since the I got it about 20 years ago at the Dayton hamfest. I'm not exactly a bulk distributor of the stuff. The ad-hominem attacks are un-called for. I was merely pointing out that the other used of lead involved boiling them off... and thus the lead was…

"20 years ago at the Dayton hamfest". yeah explains a lot. There is a lot animosity from older gen EEs towards lead free solder, lot of lies as the flux is more poisonous etc., however the point is in fact is not only personal harm, but reduction of consumption of lead at first place. The less lead is produced and thrown away the better.

Ok, so I'll keep using my old solder, and buy the new stuff next time I need more solder. (Unless of course, someone gives me more of the old stuff before then, in which case its best to use it, and keep it away from the landfill)

Re: Finding lead in Stanley's Quencher

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Av gas is what has led, not jet fuel. Av gas consumption is negligible by comparison so it’s not the impact you think.

Literally tons of aviation fuel vs. trace amounts of fresh lead solder. I think the fuel is obviously worse. Neither one may be so bad that it needs to draw excess concern of course.

Stop saying “aviation fuel” when you specifically mean the thing with lead. Aviation fuel is a generic category that captures jet fuel and other lead free variants.

It makes it sound like you don’t know what you’re talking about because you’re making an incorrect statement about a general category.

Re: Finding lead in Stanley's Quencher

#74
post #9

I have the same problem with this as with retro youtubers using lead solder. Consumers are not the only ones that matter The people working in the factoriesare exposed to lead. The people at the mines are exposed to lead. The people in shuttered ghost towns like Pitcher Oklahoma are exposed to lead. The people transporting lead are exposed to lead. People working in recycling or waste management or landfills are expo…

That retro Youtuber gripe is silly. You really think it's worth getting bent out of shape that one guy is using a little bit of lead solder to repair a valuable antique thing full of lead solder and thus keep it out of the landfill? They want to use it for technical reasons. There are many more significant sources of lead than oddball hobbyists, such as aviation fuel. Technically most hazardous chemicals we ever use…

The tiny amount of lead they use is inversly proportional to their social influence, they are literally called influencers, and they are influencing an entire generation to be indifferent to use of lead in electronics because the personal risk is easily mitiigated. None if them discuss the social or environmental risk , as if these disasters like Pitcher didnt happen or dont matter
Post reply on HN