Live data from Hacker News

Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

theguardian.com

71–80 of 202 posts

Re: Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But why is done that way? Lots of freelance chefs move between restaurants but the bill is always between the restaurant and the people who dine there.

Server is better analogy. The wage you pay/owe the waiter is direct and (mostly) separate from meal, albeit informal with only shame as a deterrent for default.

I'm not based in the US, so my servers are paid a wage directly by the restaurant.

Re: Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

#72
post #55

This seems like a good thread to mention the book "Never Pay The First Bill" by journalist Marshall Allen. I've worked in healthcare for 20+ years. I've been on the collecting side of many bills, it's a good book for patients. Contrary to popular belief most hospital systems are not evil profit seeking corpratons but just trying to keep the lights on, it's still a business though and as a patient you have the right a…

A lot of this has changed with the No Surprises Act, that specifically covers Emergency situations and others where a patient would be "reasonably expected" to believe that a service was in network. Surprise billing protections apply to most emergency services, including those provided in hospital emergency rooms, freestanding emergency departments, and urgent care centers that are licensed to provide emergency care.…

To clarify my point, your insurer spells this out to you, though you as a patient may not understand it to be the case. There is no surprise, its the expected behavior reading the literal minutiae of the giant packet your health insurer offers you. It's just that many people do not understand they have multiple additive deductibles for certain types of care.

Re: Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

#73
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because historically doctors were in private practices. I still am, as an anesthesiologist. Many of the surgeons I work with are also private. So, since neither of us is employed by the hospital, we do our own billing. If we were hospital employees, we could indeed do unified billing. That's a better analogy; your chefs are expecting to be paid by the restaurant, so it collects the bill. I am not paid by the hospital…

It's still better than billing to the hospital and the hospital billing to the patient, piling up taxes and comissions. The patient is also getting more cost transparency instead of a bundled bill one can never make sense of.

Transparency would be far more useful if it came before the service being rendered.

Obviously there are some practical limits in exceptional cases, but I can't think of another industry that has high-price services where providing estimates isn't standard.

Re: Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

#74
post #55

This seems like a good thread to mention the book "Never Pay The First Bill" by journalist Marshall Allen. I've worked in healthcare for 20+ years. I've been on the collecting side of many bills, it's a good book for patients. Contrary to popular belief most hospital systems are not evil profit seeking corpratons but just trying to keep the lights on, it's still a business though and as a patient you have the right a…

Except you're tone deaf trivializing systemic evil as a banal "business misunderstanding". I was roadtripping through Redding, CA several years back. While in line at a coffee, I ran across a young lady with a nasal infusion pump tube taped to her face arranging some paperwork. After chatting, she informed me she had Stage IV cancer and the hospitals and doctors were coming after her for every cent she had while she…

A nasty truth is when people are terminally ill, the vultures emerge. With animals too. In socialist paradise your kids dispossessed because inheritance is immoral. In capitalist paradise, dispossessed because the hospital can charge the captive buyer limitlessly. Doesn't matter what system, the order of life plays out.

Humans are chimps with high order skills to do the same chimp shit and explain it away with various fictions.

Re: Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

#76
post #7

That has included me, in the past. It is stupid easy to accidentally have a debt to a hospital. For families, sensible privacy rules at clinics can mean that it is very hard to choke point bills to a single person. To the point that I asked every time if I owed money when I did checkups to be told that we did not. Only to later find that my family did, in fact, have a bill due. For a while. Recently I'm getting it wi…

I, and my family, are now literally asking on every single thing, "Is that covered by my insurance? Will I be billed extra for that?" Like, over and over. Stupid system, stupid questions. At a recent minor surgery I must have asked it 10 times, and once for these little grippy socks they wanted to give me for my bare feet. And yup, they cost extra. So, get 'em out.

Re: Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

#77
post #31
post #7

That has included me, in the past. It is stupid easy to accidentally have a debt to a hospital. For families, sensible privacy rules at clinics can mean that it is very hard to choke point bills to a single person. To the point that I asked every time if I owed money when I did checkups to be told that we did not. Only to later find that my family did, in fact, have a bill due. For a while. Recently I'm getting it wi…

I've been getting those separate bills recently and it's driving me nuts. For one small out patient procedure I have received bills from the hospital, the doctor, the anesthesiologist, anesthesiologist nursing company, and a random surgeon I have never met that the doctor asked in for a 30 second consult (I know how long the procedure took) while I was under. Seriously considering ignoring some of these whotf-are-you…

I'm surprised medical billing scams aren't rampant, considering it's 100% normal to have a bill from from an unknown company show up asking for payment for unclear reasons for a procedure done a year ago.

Re: Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

#78
post #39

Buried midway down, they mention that the commercial health plans available to people without conventional employers (Obamacare) can (and routinely do) set deductibles as high as $9,450. And that’s in addition to the premium-which, in New York City for example, starts at $618/month for the very worst plan for an individual. Sure, that’s subsidized for lower-income households — but who among those has a spare $10K lyi…

We should've gotten single payer. The insurance lobby is just too strong, I guess. In several recent years, I would've been better off not having insurance and paying out of pocket because I never (or just barely) hit the deductible. Even when my deductible was lower, if you added up my premiums against what was covered I still probably overpaid most years. So all I've been doing is subsidizing someone else's bills w…

Insurance companies are very much to blame, sure, but that doesn't change the fact that >50% of the country rejects these systems because "socialism". If we can't get over that hurdle first then nothing will ever change.

Re: Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

#79

I have been fighting these battles for much of the last ten years and this article fails to explain a dynamic that is happening here, at least where I am (california). I'll give my most recent thing that ended up in collections (which you can easily ignore, it doesn't affect your credit at all in some states). I had a pretty intensive surgery. I had a copay, which was shown to me before the surgery. I signed it, paid…

I recently had success using CA's Dept of Insurance to assist me in convincing a health insurance company to pay a health provider what it says on my policy. I filled out the form online[0] and in less than a month, the insurance company decided to pay the full amount I expected. I only wish I had used the DOI service sooner as I wasted months getting shuffled between insurance company departments in their never ending quest to make me go away.

[0]https://www.insurance.ca.gov/01-consumers/101-help/index.cfm

Re: Majority of debtors to US hospitals now people with health insurance

#80
post #55

This seems like a good thread to mention the book "Never Pay The First Bill" by journalist Marshall Allen. I've worked in healthcare for 20+ years. I've been on the collecting side of many bills, it's a good book for patients. Contrary to popular belief most hospital systems are not evil profit seeking corpratons but just trying to keep the lights on, it's still a business though and as a patient you have the right a…

> most hospital systems are not evil profit seeking corpratons but just trying to keep the lights on

Why are they struggling so much more now than 10 or 20 years ago (when health care costs were already soaring)?

I read about a non-profit childrens hospital in some large US city that paid its CEO $7 million.

Post reply on HN