Live data from Hacker News

Is my plane a 737 MAX?

ismyplanea737max.com

71–80 of 579 posts

Re: Is my plane a 737 MAX?

#71
post #55
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's true, but the question might be whether you personally should be worried if you find yourself on a 737 Max.

The first worry as an American is having a pillar of your country's economy managed by incompetents.

Sounds a lot like "yeah sure, fear over 737 Max is overblown, but the fact that I was thinking about it in the first place says something about the current state of affairs".

https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/aaaah

Re: Is my plane a 737 MAX?

#72

Aviation is safe. An issue happened and appropriate steps have immediately happened and in the end an already incredibly safe industry will be even safer. If a car has an issue we don't blink and we loose nearly 40k people a year in the US alone, but a plane has an issue and we panic. Yes, panic. This is not rational or helpful and is a huge reason why aviation is so antiquated. You want flying cars? Stop panicking a…

/end of thread

You can apply this same argument to literally fucking everything.

Re: Is my plane a 737 MAX?

#73
post #54
post #26

Are you less safe on a 737 MAX than driving to the airport in a car? Genuinely curious, I’m trying to understand if this whole saga is statistically significant.

See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38918665 I didn't bother calculating the rate for driving to the airport, but eyeballing the figures for cars, it's probably as about as dangerous if you assume that the 737 Max were 10x more dangerous than average flying. Cars are still more dangerous than planes on a per-mile basis, but at the same time you're also traveling less miles on the car trip compared to the flight…

I'm really not sure you can amortize deaths like that to individuals. Folks are dead or they're not.

Re: Is my plane a 737 MAX?

#74

This doesn't seem correct. I checked a few flights I have coming up and it identified a United flight as not being a MAX, when United itself tells me it is. And it identifies a Southwest flight as being a MAX when it isn't.

Is it possible that the planes were changed for a different one in light of the cancellations recently and … one or the other is wrong?

Re: Is my plane a 737 MAX?

#76
post #58
post #26

Are you less safe on a 737 MAX than driving to the airport in a car? Genuinely curious, I’m trying to understand if this whole saga is statistically significant.

There’s probably more people worried about the 737 than are worried about the imperfect autopilot in their cars.

There are some of us that are just as worried about the 737 as the imperfect autopilot in others cars :)

Re: Is my plane a 737 MAX?

#77
A lot of people don't realize that the fuselage of this plane isn't even made by Boeing, it's made by Spirit AeroSystems which also makes components for Airbus.

We don't really know who to blame here until the investigation concludes.

Re: Is my plane a 737 MAX?

#78
post #26

Are you less safe on a 737 MAX than driving to the airport in a car? Genuinely curious, I’m trying to understand if this whole saga is statistically significant.

You are almost certainly safer on a 737 MAX than in a car, but that’s a low bar met easily by any modern commercial aircraft.

But "a car" is not really a fair comparison, it's usually "my car with me as a driver". Because I'd bet driving risk varies much more than flying.

Re: Is my plane a 737 MAX?

#79

Aviation is safe. An issue happened and appropriate steps have immediately happened and in the end an already incredibly safe industry will be even safer. If a car has an issue we don't blink and we loose nearly 40k people a year in the US alone, but a plane has an issue and we panic. Yes, panic. This is not rational or helpful and is a huge reason why aviation is so antiquated. You want flying cars? Stop panicking a…

Airbus seems to get by just fine.
Post reply on HN