Live data from Hacker News

Extinguishing the EV Battery Fire Hype

spectrum.ieee.org

71–72 of 72 posts

Re: Extinguishing the EV Battery Fire Hype

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah absolutely. I think a different accurate headline for the same evidence could be "It will require significant time and effort in training firefighters to bring EV batteries to an acceptable level of safety". The timeline of social adjustment to a technology is just as important as the technology itself.

The same issue is with car mechanics. Some just refuse to change. Meanwhile there are shops over here where people ship their EVs from around the country because they know their shit. They have the know-how and tools to fix EVs for a fraction of the cost the Official Solution (replace whole $thing with brand new part). TBH if you're in your 60's and a car mechanic, there's no point in learning EVs unless you're perso…

Same thing with electricians and home electrification. In general, decarbonization technologies are significantly front-running the trades and training necessary to scale them. But that's totally normal (if unfortunate). There's a chicken and egg problem with these things, but viable technologies must come first, and adaptation to them come later.

But recognizing that this is normal doesn't mean it isn't going to require work and investment to make it all pencil out. People - like me - who want to see these technologies succeed need to be just as attuned to this and not downplay it or take it for granted that people will come along for the ride if they don't yet see the benefit to themselves.

Re: Extinguishing the EV Battery Fire Hype

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But I think it is much less likely to occur You think . The point of gathering data and studying it is to attempt to replace our animal-brain intuitions with real evidence. I honestly haven't looked into the evidence on this enough either way, since I haven't yet seriously researched purchasing an electric vehicle. But I know that I have a big tank of gasoline sitting directly underneath a portion of my childrens'…

It's worse than that! You (well, I'm guessing, I don't actually know you) have this wire just bringing foreign ideas, and crazy people's written thoughts, from all over the world, and you pipe them straight into your brain, with no helmet on. And this happens right next to your kids! You're a mad man!

Too true!
Post reply on HN