Live data from Hacker News

The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

maxread.substack.com

71–80 of 81 posts

Re: The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

#71
post #6

This post spends a lot of time criticizing the "pointless line breaks" but not a lot of time on why this is a problem or "must be stopped". Block or mute the people that annoy you and move on; problem solved.

"must be stopped" is a meme which means "is annoying"

It’s the opposite of “must be protected” which means “is something I like”

Re: The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

#72

Sometimes I am jealous of these people. They arent doing the corporate grind, and they arent even really doing the startup grind. They are shilling stuff on the internet and avoiding spending their lives working. I know a few, they live great, though frugal lives. I go to my job at prestigious big Co and often wonder who the smart one is, me or them

I'm not jealous. People with the exact same skills are landing jobs at McKinsey selling this bullshit to the C-suite. These guys are at best scraping the bottom of the barrel (Twitter impressions) to sell a course.

Re: The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

#73

I'm not really concerned. More likely, we are currently experiencing a calibration phase for a new technology, during which individuals are attempting to gauge others' understanding and interest in it. Right now, everybody is shouting "You have to look at this awesome thing!!", while in fact others are already aware of it, or even tired of it. Hence the complaints. This will pass quickly.

The issue isn't that they're shilling AI. It's that the algorithm rewards these low-value hustlers because they create "engagement" with their spammy threads that pollute the feed.

I have seen this exact pattern with other things like "front-end development", "stocks and investing" and many other topics where there's money to be made by selling something to somebody. It gives the whole of Twitter a cynical, soullessness that's growing by the day.

Re: The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

#74
post #30

Sometimes I am jealous of these people. They arent doing the corporate grind, and they arent even really doing the startup grind. They are shilling stuff on the internet and avoiding spending their lives working. I know a few, they live great, though frugal lives. I go to my job at prestigious big Co and often wonder who the smart one is, me or them

Don't be fooled by the glamorous facade of such "influencers". It's as tough a grind as any corporate job. There is 24x7 demand for new content. You have to compete with a million others in the space, and it is next to impossible to set yourself apart. Only the top 0.1% have any real viewership and are making money. For the rest, the "living frugally" part you mention is likely not by choice.

Yes, for anything with essentially zero barrier to entry you better believe you will be competing against everyone on the planet.

Re: The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

#75
post #6

This post spends a lot of time criticizing the "pointless line breaks" but not a lot of time on why this is a problem or "must be stopped". Block or mute the people that annoy you and move on; problem solved.

It's contributing to the massive signal-to-noise decline on tech related topics on Twitter lately. As an open-source AI developer myself I'm discouraged because anything I'd release would be drowned out by hypebros.

I have never had success with Twitter’s algorithm or expecting their search to surface good results for topics I care about. A much more effective way is to find experts in that field and follow them directly. Your feed will have a much higher signal to noise ratio.

Re: The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

#77
post #68
post #48

Not to be dismissive but it seems like a skill issue to me. I have the thread emoji muted, that does 90% of the work. I had to click “don’t show me this guy” ( not “don’t show me this topic”) on maybe half a dozen that slipped through, and then it seems like the algorithm got the message. Just curate better and the problem goes away.

There are hundreds if not thousands of people doing this exact hustle. You'll be spending a lot of time trying to decapitate that hydra.

Whatever algorithm they’re using is a capable assistant, I only had to decapitate a few heads and it learned to slay that hydra for me.

Re: The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Linkedin Broetry is such a great phrase!

The phrase was coined years ago partially by the same writer: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/why-are-these-p... LinkedIn discourse hasn't changed since.

I hadn't realised this had a name (I'd always just called it LinkedIn-spam), and "broem" is perfect.

Re: The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

#79

This is so funny. I've noticed these lame influencers shilling AI strategies on twitter even though I don't follow them. But the algorithm sees engagement from others so it thinks I'll like it too. There's a pattern developing on twitter (and other socials). Life coach types, just shill the next big thing. It was Crypto, then NFTs, now AI. Wonder what will be next?

It was actually kind of AI before, too. Everyone seems to have determinedly forgotten about it now, but there was a brief period a few years back when chatbots were going to take over the world (remember Microsoft Tay), and a lot of VCs lost a lot of money. Then everyone agreed never to talk about it again, seemingly.

Re: The A.I. business influencer guys must be stopped

#80
post #58
post #53

1. If you're still on bird-app, I feel it's important to ignore the "For you" tab and strictly look at the "Following" view, and follow only people whose posts you consistently appreciate. The noise ratio is so high now, and not just about AI. > What they share across platforms and fields is less any particular insight and more a deep and abiding faith in the accuracy and power of a still-developing technology about…

...For as long as Musk allows people to ignore those who have paid him to shove their words in front of as many eyeballs as possible. I really don't expect the "Following" view to remain safe from this for long.

Changes like that will hasten Twitter's loss of relevance, though; there's a bit of a balance there. If you literally can't use Twitter without getting the blue-check brigade in your face, more people will leave.
Post reply on HN