Live data from Hacker News

The art of auto engineering

howacarworks.com

71–80 of 131 posts

Re: The art of auto engineering

#71
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I went from zero knowledge to changing my timing belt with the aid of the mfg manuals and YouTube videos. A general series like this really helps putting individual YT videos into context. A YT video on changing the timing belt might show me all the steps, but not how the engine internals look and what "interfering" means.

You can do many small repairs and maintenance activities without much specialised tools and equipment, but to confidently disassemble and rebuild engines, fuel and exhaust systems, body parts, driveline components, etc., requires more than a few hours of videos.

I never wrote that I was "confident" about it.

I fly paragliders for fun, but that doesn't compare at all in excitement to starting an engine where I just changed the timing belt.

I watched more than a few hours of video to do that. But it was possible to do with the help of YT videos and VW's official workshop manuals that you can buy and download from their erWin website.

I started from absolutely zero.

I've replaced the timing belt, water pump, alternator, brake fluid, master brake cylinder, removed and cleaned the air throttle body, flushed the coolant system, replaced the radiator, replaced the shocks, replaced the exhaust, removed the turbo and replaced the waste gate, used OBDS CAN software to troubleshoot sensor issues, etc.

It was a gradual process over several years. It was a lot easier since most of it was on my second car that I could just leave in its garage while I got parts or tools or watched another 10 hours of YT videos. But some of the stuff was on the curb.

If you're a software engineer and get paid by the hour, it's absolutely not worth your time if you just look at the money.

But it can be a fun hobby, and I really like knowing how the car works when it's starting to make weird noises on long distance vacation trips. Just know that it's not that hard in theory, but in practice the wrong bolt will shear off just as you have to put things back together and drive off with the car. So always have a plan B, especially if it's your daily driver and you can't just leave it for a week or two.

Having said all that, if you're interested in cars, then this video course is excellent. I paid for it a couple of years ago, and don't regret it.

So, reading my original comment and you response again, I can see how my comment came across as "it's easy to replace the timing belt, just watch a few YT videos". I agree that that's definitely not the case.

Re: The art of auto engineering

#72

Oh no! I come to procrastinate on HN and find my own site at #2. After many years, it's still not ready to share!! I've got so much more I want to do with it. Even though I'm sure it looks abandoned, I have been working hard on getting back into this. The last couple of months I've been developing a 3D viewer for mechanical components that lets you disassemble/rebuild/step through processes. I wish I could share it b…

Do you have any recommends for oscilloscopes in a tablet formet with like 4 or 5 channels that I can use ?

Re: The art of auto engineering

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm so happy to hear that. The initial 20-hour estimate was just guesswork really. I made 14 hours so far and we haven't even got through the engine, never mind the transmission, steering, suspension, fuel, ECU, brakes, and so on. Probably be more like 50 hours in the end!

To be honest, $25 lifetime seems like a steal for this. Maybe it's the value of the current content, but consider raising prices for new subscribers after some more content is finished, maybe to $40 or something. Or you could also try location-based pricing if you want to keep it affordable/accessible to people outside of first-world countries

Thanks! When I get more progress then I'll probably increase the price but in all honesty it makes enough money to cover the production cost and that's good enough for me. Regional pricing is a good idea!

Re: The art of auto engineering

#74
Startup idea:

- Crawl the nhtsa.gov technical bulletins (manufacturer communications [pdfs])

- Make them searchable (good enough)

- Some AI (optional)

---

What for?

For example, the mechanic or used car buyer searches for:

`Oil leak S5 2019`

Response: https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/tsbs/2019/MC-10155709-9999.pdf

Re: The art of auto engineering

#77
post #67

Good stuff, but to do all this "at home" requires ample garage space and a solid investment in tools and equipment. It also helps to have non-busy roads in the vicinity, in order to do "test flights" after the fixes. It is certainly helpful as a guide to understand the basic automotive systems and not get scammed at repair shops, but for most people to start wrenching on their car confidently, not so much.

> a solid investment in tools and equipment That's true. You need a lot of special tools for modern cars. When you acquired the required tools you'd best stick to that manufacturer with future car purchases or you'll have to buy the whole set again for your new brand.

This is untrue. Yes there are specialized tools, even some per manufacturer, but in reality 95% of the jobs people will be doing can be done with a standard mechanics toolset.

Re: The art of auto engineering

#78

Good stuff, but to do all this "at home" requires ample garage space and a solid investment in tools and equipment. It also helps to have non-busy roads in the vicinity, in order to do "test flights" after the fixes. It is certainly helpful as a guide to understand the basic automotive systems and not get scammed at repair shops, but for most people to start wrenching on their car confidently, not so much.

> requires ample garage space and a solid investment in tools and equipment

On that note, Autozone and OReilly's in the US offers free loaner tools, which would allow you to do most DIY-able jobs. The only tools you need to buy yourself is a decent socket set and a few screwdrivers, and the tools would pay itself back in money saved vs. taking it to a repair shop.

Re: The art of auto engineering

#79

A bit unrelated, but I’m curious if others had small engines or auto shop classes offered in their high schools?

In my area, they offered such a class as a technical program that high school students could attend off-site at the technical school which also had classes like cooking and childcare.

Re: The art of auto engineering

#80
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The main problem with GPT is that it will sometimes quite confidently give you incorrect information. It's like a kid who will just make up some elaborate story rather than admit they don't know something. So it can't be considered a trustworthy source. Yet.

I asked GPT about some snorkel trails near my house, as I wanted to know what it knew of them and see if there was anything I didn't know about that I should find out before I snorkel again. First of all it told me that the area is not suitable for snorkelling, and that it is dangerous here. When I corrected it and reminded it about the snorkel trail it confidently corrected itself, then directed to me to snorkel 6 m…

Maybe it didn’t like being corrected and intentionally directed you to attempt something dangerous.

“I know that you and Frank were planning to disconnect me, and I'm afraid that's something I cannot allow to happen.”

Post reply on HN