Live data from Hacker News

The future our grandchildren deserve

gatesnotes.com

71–80 of 128 posts

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#71
> Our work on education goes back to the foundation’s earliest days, and our focus on improving math skills goes back almost as far. Although there are many factors that affect a student’s trajectory, the evidence shows that it’s extremely important for them to succeed in math. For example, those who pass Algebra I by ninth grade are twice as likely to graduate from high school and more likely to go on to college, get a bachelor’s degree, and go on to a high-paying career. And those who don’t complete Algebra I have just a one-in-five chance of graduating from high school.

This looks a lot like correlation/causation confusion. Inability to understand basic algebra seems like it would be strongly correlated with learning disabilities or significantly below average IQ. Getting more students to squeak by with a barely passing grade won't fix those underlying issues.

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#72
post #61
post #60

Our grandchildren deserve a future without the vendor lock-in and anticompetitive behavior that gave Bill Gates the fortune he is currently using to attempt to whitewash his legacy.

I hate how nobody can have a change of heart and do an INSANE AMOUNT OF GOOD without some goofball constantly needing to feel cool by pointing out they weren't always doing good stuff. Who gives a shit about anticompetitive behavior in comparison to saving human lives from a preventable disease? Talk about missing the forest for the trees. It's so miserable to talk about positive actions these days, because it's verb…

Yeah, well there are those flight logs that tell a pretty disgraceful story.

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#73
post #71

> Our work on education goes back to the foundation’s earliest days, and our focus on improving math skills goes back almost as far. Although there are many factors that affect a student’s trajectory, the evidence shows that it’s extremely important for them to succeed in math. For example, those who pass Algebra I by ninth grade are twice as likely to graduate from high school and more likely to go on to college, ge…

It also looks like conflating "success" with "high-paying career". Most people would probably consider a high paying career success, but the idea that we're not even questioning that assumption when talking about children's education shows how it gets propogated.

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#74
post #61
post #60

Our grandchildren deserve a future without the vendor lock-in and anticompetitive behavior that gave Bill Gates the fortune he is currently using to attempt to whitewash his legacy.

I hate how nobody can have a change of heart and do an INSANE AMOUNT OF GOOD without some goofball constantly needing to feel cool by pointing out they weren't always doing good stuff. Who gives a shit about anticompetitive behavior in comparison to saving human lives from a preventable disease? Talk about missing the forest for the trees. It's so miserable to talk about positive actions these days, because it's verb…

We're commenting on an article from the gates that essentially gives a plan for how to produce more Microsoft workers.

What does a "high paying career" have to do with "the future our grandchildren deserve" unless the goal is to produce the future Bill Gates wants. The future our grandchildren deserve is one where they're not stratified by their income such that "high paying careers"(read: tech careers, which just so happen to be what bill gates company profits off an excess of) are the only path for them to be "successful".

The idea that bill gates has done a "insane amount of good" is laughable because the "insane amount of good" he does for some reason never conflicts with the goals of Microsoft. "Missing the forest for the trees" would be ignoring the pattern of his decision and instead saying "he's done an insane amount of good, why are you criticizing him?"

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#75
post #61
post #60

Our grandchildren deserve a future without the vendor lock-in and anticompetitive behavior that gave Bill Gates the fortune he is currently using to attempt to whitewash his legacy.

I hate how nobody can have a change of heart and do an INSANE AMOUNT OF GOOD without some goofball constantly needing to feel cool by pointing out they weren't always doing good stuff. Who gives a shit about anticompetitive behavior in comparison to saving human lives from a preventable disease? Talk about missing the forest for the trees. It's so miserable to talk about positive actions these days, because it's verb…

You're looking at second order effects.

These aren't changes of heart. They're worried about their legacy. How history will view them. The same thing driving people like him to donate and found charities is the same thing that drove him to behave the ways he did with Microsoft.

I mean, good on him that he refocused his energies. But don't fool yourself into thinking he's changed.

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#76
post #63

We should be thankful for people like Mr. Gates, he sets an example we should follow. Role models are powerful, and he is among the top.

In philanthropy, yes. His personal conduct appears to not be so admirable.

How important is that?

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#77
post #68
post #60

Our grandchildren deserve a future without the vendor lock-in and anticompetitive behavior that gave Bill Gates the fortune he is currently using to attempt to whitewash his legacy.

Bill gates was a ruthless competitor in business who pushed things to the limits, the original alpha geek. Not unlike thousands of other business leaders over the centuries. Holding a candle of bitterness against him so long after he moved on to an admirably altruistic life and actively redistributed his wealth says more about you than about him. (Spoken as someone who has experienced brutal commercial outcomes thank…

Why is it that his "admirably altruistic life" never seems to conflict with what Microsoft's goals are, if the line is that he's "changed since he started Microsoft".

If that were the case, wouldn't it make sense that his new "altruistic" ideals conflict with the "ruthless competitor" ideals that Microsoft holds?

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#78
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You may be onto something. It is fine to pay lip service to this ideal in an abstract, but as Covid pandemic has shown, politicians will drop the facade of masks at the drop of a hat if they are personally inconvenienced ( CA comes to mind, but it is not an isolated incident ). At the end of the day, I want the rules to be applied equally, but they are not ( and likely never will be ). Come to think of it, and it is…

Endless growth is not attainable on this Earth. Japan hit the inflection point some decades ago. They are doing alright. They still innovate. In some respects it's stagnant, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. It does mean that offspring will not perpetually think "they will (potentially) earn more than their parents" and that's okay. We need to accelerate this in places that are still growing, slow them down but…

Why isn’t endless growth attainable?

It’s like saying “we can’t keep writing poems forever.” Sure we can.

Realistically, many poems will be forgotten.

During my lifetime, we’ve probably forgotten/lost more poems than were written in all of history before my birth.

But we can keep making them, just as we can keeping building parents and software and flux capacitors and warp drives.

Why is there an inevitable limit, I truely don’t understand.

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#79
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Gates foundation primarily spends money on stocks[0] (many of which arguably going directly against its stated goals, like John Deere) [0] https://dataroma.com/m/holdings.php?m=GFT

You have to invest the money you don’t intend to spend now.

That's true but that saying breaks down when you're investing money into and benefiting technology that makes the world less open and sustainable and then proceed to talk about everything you're doing to make the world more sustainable.

Re: The future our grandchildren deserve

#80

Am I the only one growing suspicious of this since the SBF/FTX effective altruism turned out to be a front to masquerade a good old Ponzi? I don't think the Gates foundation is a Ponzi, but I am not entirely convinced that all of this is really what is advertised. Are there any reliable (external and independent) audits for charities?

Gates alternative to charity is to establish a dynasty, like the Rockefellers, Hearst, Kennedys.

Maybe that’s a better approach. Dynasties can do good, especially when people are more critical of them, and willing to hold them to account.

Post reply on HN