Live data from Hacker News

Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

medusajs.com

71–80 of 175 posts

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#71

The article focuses on the UI, which is good, but the number one reason McMaster is the tops shopping experience (IMHO) is that they have a rock solid taxonomy. Every single product is meticulously categorized a dozen different ways, allowing me to drill down the feature tree to get exactly to the part I want. On Amazon even the product categories that have a few filters are hopelessly difficult to navigate. I'm stuc…

Indeed, one can search by your area's local trade name for an item and still find it in their catalog, even if no one else in the country calls it that!

For an example that's not hyper-local, search "roll pin," which about half the world uses to describe that particular item. For a more dramatic example, search "hickey."

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#72
I’m surprised nobody has mentioned information density yet. I find the modern practice of adding so much spacing and making the font size gigantic extremely annoying. Sometimes you need detail- and it’s harder to put together a well designed information dense way of displaying that detail. Instead it seems everyone decides to just ignore that detail and make you click everywhere and scroll all day to find what you need.

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Naming things can be very hard. For this, it helps to have the paper catalog to flip through.

One of the nice things about McMaster in my mind is the way their website is organized very much like their paper catalog. It's not as good as the paper catalog for casual browsing, but it does mean that when you're not quite sure what you actually need you can "flip through" the website and have a decent chance of spotting something like it. Unfortunately McMaster is a little stingy with their paper catalog, I think…

You can ask Uline to have a note added to all your orders not to pack a catalogue.

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#74
I have a gripe about McMaster.

If I'm looking to buy some 316 stainless bolts, I'd like to see links to the applicable nuts for that size/material/threads/etc. For certain sizes, the nut selection can be limited and might not meet my needs. Then, I have to start over with 304 or something else. In my most recent case, I had to order some of the components from a different store.

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#75
It is great, but one annoyance is it's pretty easy to buy a small threaded coupler with one side blank instead of threaded like the other side--uncommonly needed parts like this will show up in my searches higher than the more common variant, and it takes careful reading of the specs to differentiate.

I like how rockauto puts heart symbols next to the commonly purchased parts.

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#76

There's many things to love about the design, but the fact that they use actual anchor tags and override the default behavior with JS is extremely frustrating and makes opening in a new tab impossible. When I'm looking for parts I tend to want to open up several categories or parts across a few tabs and they make it impossible. Horizontal scrolling is also remapped to scroll vertically as well, which breaks the track…

What is it that doesn’t work?

I started at the home page and could middle click on both images and blue text, down to individual items. (Using Chrome from Linux.)

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#77

Oh McMaster... how I love thee. They pioneered same day delivery in 2001. I worked at Idealab in Pasadena California. We ordered SO much from them that they would deliver to us (and others in the area) directly and daily. If you had your order in by 10am (11 if you were SUPER lucky and there were a lot of orders to process) the truck would show up at ~2ish. This was 2001... WAY before Amazon Prime 2 day deliver, let…

You may enjoy Amazon Random Shopper. https://randomshopper.tumblr.com/post/35454415921/randomized...

Brilliant

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Naming things can be very hard. For this, it helps to have the paper catalog to flip through.

One of the nice things about McMaster in my mind is the way their website is organized very much like their paper catalog. It's not as good as the paper catalog for casual browsing, but it does mean that when you're not quite sure what you actually need you can "flip through" the website and have a decent chance of spotting something like it. Unfortunately McMaster is a little stingy with their paper catalog, I think…

I can't ethically purchase anything from U Line any more. Does anyone know of an alternative supplier?

The U Line family has historically come out against things ranging from flouridation to Martin Luther King and currently supports election deniers / anti Semites. They are the number one donor to the Republican party:

https://www.propublica.org/article/uline-uihlein-election-de...

Their working conditions are unbelievably sexist / restrictive (similar articles are available from journalists, if you don't trust glass door):

https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Employee-Review-Uline-RVW7...

E.g.:

> Uline is privately owned and therefore does not have any stockholders to answer to. The dress code is business professional, which means guys have to wear ties. That in and of itself is not unheard of, what is unheard of is that women have to wear knee length skirts and panty hoes during the winter months and only around Memorial day can they stop wearing panty hoes. Hey Uline this is 2015 not 1950! This dress code is a directive from Liz the owner. Yes, women can wear pant suits but of course they have to match. I'm trying to drive home that this place is run like a cult and it will destroy you if you stay there long enough.

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#79
As soon as the homepage rendered, I felt my whole upper body relax slightly. What a remarkable experience from a web site. It was clear, the contrast felt right, the meaning and organisation were plain and comfortable. Nothing interrupted me, nothing shouted at me.

I couldn't find the screws I wanted, tho'.

Re: Best ecommerce UX practices from mcmaster.com

#80
post #67
post #4

A huge advantage of McMaster I didn't see enumerated is the 3D models - for nearly every fastener, and for certain other products, you can instantly grab a 3D model and bring it right into your CAD design. As far as I know no one else offers this, definitely not at the scale McMaster's dataset offers. An annoyance of McMaster I didn't see enumerated is how they don't show you the shipping cost until after transaction…

They started showing shipping costs a few years ago. It was also my main complaint.

That’s it, then. McMaster-Carr is perfect.

(Too bad my organization’s procurement has become completely screwed up in the last 2-3 years…)

Post reply on HN