Live data from Hacker News

UV Devices Could Keep Indoor Air Free of Viruses

nature.com

71–72 of 72 posts

Re: UV Devices Could Keep Indoor Air Free of Viruses

#71
I'm a big fan of using UV for germicidal purposes, but I get extremely concerned when people propose using it in rooms where people are present, like the "just put it high up in a vaulted ceiling" approach discussed in the article. People can get eye damage from halogen lamps with cracked filters in school gymnasiums[1], and those ceilings are generally higher than you'd see in most other types of room.

The potential to end up deploying something that ends up being another asbestos-type "oops, we gave an entire generation cataracts and skin cancer" situation really concerns me. I'd want to see either some very long term research indicating that it didn't happen with far-UV light at all, or that the lights were in fixtures that somehow completely prevented the people below from being exposed.

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/65/wr/mm6511a4.htm

Re: UV Devices Could Keep Indoor Air Free of Viruses

#72
post #4

When you talk to Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) most are uncomfortable with UV. Reason being that while you can get rid of viruses, you can also create volatile compounds. Our homes' air is like a soup of natural and synthetic chemicals. From your flooring wear to your decor off-gassing to cooking, there are elements in your air that may be safe as they are, but they can completely change when they hit something volatile l…

Most quality whole-home HEPA air filters I know of are available with UV lights that can be added to the mix to further help reduce the viral load in the house. And excessive ozone production is specifically avoided.

For those units, I don't think there's anything to be concerned about here, except the added cost of the UV lighting and what might happen if you (or a technician) were accidentally exposed to the UV lighting during maintenance of the equipment.

IMO, you're going to have to provide some extraordinary evidence if you want to claim UV health risks beyond these two factors.

Post reply on HN