Live data from Hacker News

Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 90 posts

Re: Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

#71

Can you prove your channel was active and not dead just for squatting?

For what it's worth, I couldn't find any links anywhere on the net (Google, Bing...) to " https://t.me/kissfm ". I've searched for even small Telegram channels I follow, and they all show up in search results.

I'm one of the https://kissfm.md developers and the channel @kissfm was supposed to be integrated with this site in the upcoming year.

Re: Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

#72
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Regardless of whether you consider this action just, it is not gaslighting. Gaslighting has a specific definition, and this isn't it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaslighting

> manipulating someone so as to make them question their own reality. That's what he did. Telling users it is their own fault that he had to take their names and sell them. You were causing issues, because you did not log in for three months.

Justifying your actions isn't gaslighting. Blaming someone isn't gaslighting.

Gaslighting involves presenting a false history of things that did not happen. There is real data here that there are a huge number of inactive accounts.

Re: Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

#73
post #8

what's the guarantee that tomorrow my private channels will not become public instead and all my personal data will be exposed!? wtf is happening with durov!?!?!

Nothing, they took away usernames which were holded by squatters.

having a roadmap to integrate this channel with the site https://kissfm.md is a squatting for you!? Applause (sarcasm)!

Re: Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

#74
Only inactive usernames were taken away by them (and not the active ones). While it's good to have a memorable one, you'd run the risk of "spam attacks". I am not sure how the proposed blockchain (TON) will work (it's claimed to be immutable), but then this is their prerogative to earn money.

Re: Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then my advice about sticking to a dignified tone and knowing the rules still applies. Happy to have more people sharing but there's a reason HN isn't the same vibe as Reddit.

And there's also a reason lobsters isn't the same vibe as HN.

What's the vibe of Lobster?

Re: Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've successfully taken a username from a squatter by reaching out to github support. As long as the user doesn't have active private stuff they might be willing to help you get the username.

That's not an option any more. GitHub used to offer this, but as of about 12 months ago, the policy changed and they will not release a name that is inactive regardless of how long it has been inactive.

Using recent activity as a metric seems like it would age finished projects out of the github platform. Active projects that have switched version control several times in their history might refer to previous versions on github without github itself being aware of the connection.

At the free level I could see unmodified forks and anything marked private disappearing over time, then culling empty accounts. If I created an account, forked a project, and then left, how many months would need to pass before I'd be surprised that my account hadn't been recycled without my active consent?

Re: Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For what it's worth, I couldn't find any links anywhere on the net (Google, Bing...) to " https://t.me/kissfm ". I've searched for even small Telegram channels I follow, and they all show up in search results.

I'm one of the https://kissfm.md developers and the channel @kissfm was supposed to be integrated with this site in the upcoming year.

Fair enough! However, if the channel was inactive, I guess it's hard to distinguish an upcoming project with a squatted channel. Maybe contact Telegram?

Re: Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm one of the https://kissfm.md developers and the channel @kissfm was supposed to be integrated with this site in the upcoming year.

Fair enough! However, if the channel was inactive, I guess it's hard to distinguish an upcoming project with a squatted channel. Maybe contact Telegram?

Already dropped them a message, but not sure they'll ever get back to me.

Re: Telegram has stolen my channel's username to sell it on auction

#80

It happened to channels and groups that were inactive for a long time. Durov did mention this in a message a few months ago that username squatters were becoming a problem. And I was mad at first but it was equally my fault for leaving my public group inactive for more than 10 months, which is probably why the username disappeared. It's a real problem on other social media websites too. For example, a totally inactiv…

My issue is that any external links to my channel now no longer works. Luckily I can update some of the links, but I can't do that with tweets. I'll just have to be better at uploading so this hopefully won't happen again.

Yeah it's definitely an inconvenience. I hope Telegram team listens to the feedback.
Post reply on HN