Live data from Hacker News

USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

theverge.com

71–80 of 140 posts

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#71
This part is so exciting:

> it’ll now also have to list a charging speed like 60W or 240W.

Ah, no more trying to do determine what dielectric the cable is using: they’ll label the cable with how fast the charge can propagate through the cable. A significant blow for consumer choice!

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#72
post #24

So if I've got two computers, each with a port labelled 40 Gbps and a USB cable labelled 40 Gbps, what's the protocol I can use to copy files at close to that? FWIW I used to run PLIP back in the nineties (IP over parallel port) to share my dialup Internet connection between my desktop and "laptop", so I'm not afraid of anything.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/design/co... > the Ethernet over USB4 interdomain protocol, also known as USB4NET enables two USB4 PCs to establish a network connection between each other when connected using a USB4 cable, akin to connecting an ethernet cable between network cards on two PCs. I wrote about this a month ago at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32714807 it gets confusing because t…

It's rather unfortunate that you still have dig so deep to look up the auto-assigned IPs and then manually type them in Explorer.

It really ought to be as simple as file transfers from a PC to a phone - plug the cable, each side gets a prompt on whether it wants to provide access, and once you confirm, the other end shows it in the drive/device tree in Explorer.

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#73
post #71

This part is so exciting: > it’ll now also have to list a charging speed like 60W or 240W. Ah, no more trying to do determine what dielectric the cable is using: they’ll label the cable with how fast the charge can propagate through the cable. A significant blow for consumer choice!

It's even worse. A 20W USB-PD charger might indeed put out 20W, but not at the voltage your device needs. It might put out 20W at one voltage, but only 10W at another.

The whole thing is a goddamn mess, and it's a mess because the alliance is a cartel, not an actually useful technical standards group. They're a bunch of fat swine contributing little to nothing but extorting licensing fees from everyone.

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#74
post #67
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Once the color system is established, I would expect device packaging and/or manuals to indicate the compatible colors.

But why are you defending it with novel solutions and colour grading schemes for something which could simply not be named the same thing because it isn't the same thing?

I have a bunch of USB-C cables. Some will fry things some won't. How will a naming convention help me keep track of them once they get chucked into in the basket under my coffee table

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#75

At this point USB might as well auction their branding rights like sports stadiums: - USB Coke Zero - USB House of Dragon streaming exclusively on HBO - USB Crypto.com Consumers, Devices, and cables could continue ignoring it all but at least the consortium could have a new revenue stream.

Well, there are worse things. Just consider USBet.gg and USB brought to you by Raid Shadow Legends.

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#76
post #46

So if I've got two computers, each with a port labelled 40 Gbps and a USB cable labelled 40 Gbps, what's the protocol I can use to copy files at close to that? FWIW I used to run PLIP back in the nineties (IP over parallel port) to share my dialup Internet connection between my desktop and "laptop", so I'm not afraid of anything.

Just don't expect to get more than ~20 Gbps due to undocumented controller bottlenecks.

Look up how much 10Gbit Ethernet hardware costs, and you'll find that 20Gbps is already a great value at this time.

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#77
post #70
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly I'd prefer that! Have fried two devices using the wrong damn cable/ charger. Sure the device should have had better power IC's etc to prevent anything from happening when I plugged in the wrong one, but still, they all look the damn same!

> fried two devices using the wrong damn cable/ charger Doubt the USB-IF can do anything about that. Those chargers either don't use the USB logo or use it illegally without passing compliance testing. Don't buy from those sellers.

Well one of them is from a company called Nintendo

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#78

At this point USB might as well auction their branding rights like sports stadiums: - USB Coke Zero - USB House of Dragon streaming exclusively on HBO - USB Crypto.com Consumers, Devices, and cables could continue ignoring it all but at least the consortium could have a new revenue stream.

Stop giving them ideas straight out of Idiocracy

sobs in mountain dew

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#79
post #64
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

USB does mean that already! If you have two spec-compliant devices, connecting them with a USB cable should never cause one to get fried.

But that's not how it actually goes. Many devices aren't actually spec compliant

that's pretty much not true anymore. the wild west after USB-C first came out is over, testers are available enough and sketchy vendors get shamed loudly enough that unless you're buying cables at unreasonably dodgy stores, you're going to get something spec-compliant.

Re: USB kills off SuperSpeed branding

#80

> “As we started to update our branding we did a lot of focus group studies with many different types of consumers,” he tells The Verge, “and none of those people understood the messaging and the branding, and they don’t understand revision control or spec names.” You didn't need a focus group to tell you this (though I'm glad they did one). Just look at every single comment thread on HN about USB branding, at this p…

if you're making design decisions based on HN comment threads instead of proper focus groups, you're going to end up with a very weird product.
Post reply on HN