Live data from Hacker News

What I’ve learned from users

paulgraham.com

71–80 of 339 posts

Re: What I’ve learned from users

#71
post #53

More of a meta discussion, but it's interesting that pretty much all HN threads on PG's recent essays have a strong, negative sentiment. My guess is that this is explained by 3 factors: 1) The quantity and quality of new ideas in PG's essays is declining. 2) Readers' expectations of quality in PG's essays is increasing. 3) The pool of disenfranchised readers is growing. The quantity and quality of new ideas is decrea…

Or the IT industry is just full of participation trophies and the new grey beards just cbf participating in a toxic community that can't handle a single opinion outside their own narrative.

I was gonna upvote this comment but then I realized it's not clear who you're saying is the toxic community that can't handle the opinion.

Re: What I’ve learned from users

#73
post #53

More of a meta discussion, but it's interesting that pretty much all HN threads on PG's recent essays have a strong, negative sentiment. My guess is that this is explained by 3 factors: 1) The quantity and quality of new ideas in PG's essays is declining. 2) Readers' expectations of quality in PG's essays is increasing. 3) The pool of disenfranchised readers is growing. The quantity and quality of new ideas is decrea…

> I feel badly about this because anyone who has interacted with PG irl knows he's as kind-hearted as people come. Irrelevant even if it is true.

[deleted]

Re: What I’ve learned from users

#74
post #53

More of a meta discussion, but it's interesting that pretty much all HN threads on PG's recent essays have a strong, negative sentiment. My guess is that this is explained by 3 factors: 1) The quantity and quality of new ideas in PG's essays is declining. 2) Readers' expectations of quality in PG's essays is increasing. 3) The pool of disenfranchised readers is growing. The quantity and quality of new ideas is decrea…

My personal impression of this site is that it's generally very negative. I'm sure the response is to say that's just me noticing the negativity and not the positivity. Maybe so. I'd like to see some cold, hard numbers on it, though.

Re: What I’ve learned from users

#75
PG is great. What would we do without him? We want a PG in the arena at all times.

This article doesn't hit the mark. Startup people don't listen, because they're trying to create something new, that nobody else understands (or people who understand are a 'parallel thought threat' like Newton and Liebniz). Counter-intuitivity is in the ballpark, but not quite "it".

Really what an inventor/entrepreneur does is to specialize in a direction or idea no-one else gets or no-one else will understand the way to make it, until it's in MVP or prototype stage. How can that person slam the breaks on the train and start doing rational, sensible things that could extinguish the light of discovery/creation? Not saying that's a good thing, it's what it is.

There's a weird trend online to keep blaming school for poor thinking. It's a cool rhetorical device. Doesn't work for me though. I went to a good school that challenged me to open my mind and is also the basis for faith and way of thinking that gets me to discovery. The patterns I see that others don't, is partially because I hold a tiny candle flame for an older way of thinking that is sorely needed in some spaces.

There's also a quiet truth that there's now two truths. One truth for the established and comfortable, another truth for the man battling for his soul's light. They point mostly in different directions and they don't understand each other so much. It's physically painful to try and synthesize those two truths into one.

More transparency in communication is the way to go. Everyone needs to admit only the old wisdom and knowledge is firm and stable. The more we can admit we don't know what's going on as we go forward, the more we can relate... my probably-wrong 0.02c

Re: What I’ve learned from users

#76
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or the IT industry is just full of participation trophies and the new grey beards just cbf participating in a toxic community that can't handle a single opinion outside their own narrative.

I was gonna upvote this comment but then I realized it's not clear who you're saying is the toxic community that can't handle the opinion.

That's the genius of it.

Re: What I’ve learned from users

#77
post #18

I adore pg’s essay. But this time something is tripping my spider sense, so I had to take a closer look (at my spider sense, and a bit on the essay too). This is the first time an essay feels like a sale pitch. Specifically, a sale pitch for YC. I’ve read pg’s essay about YC for about 15 years, and this is the first one I have that feeling. This one is a bit too abstract. I’m getting the idea that YC can help founder…

Of course YC has some secrets in their recipe.

I wouldn't consider that a given. YC is very generous with their information. They put all their trainings online, and even all their legal documents.

They realize that their value is in the people, not the artifacts.

Re: What I’ve learned from users

#78
post #65
post #56

> We learned that the hard way, in the notorious "batch that broke YC" in the summer of 2012. Up till that point we treated the partners as a pool. When a startup requested office hours, they got the next available slot posted by any partner. That meant every partner had to know every startup. This worked fine up to 60 startups, but when the batch grew to 80, everything broke. The founders probably didn't realize any…

I was curious to see what companies were part of the S12 batch, and who were the most notable. Among the 80 or so in that group, big winners were Coinbase, Instacart, and Zapier. https://techcrunch.com/2012/08/21/yc-demo-day-s12/

With Coinbase ipo'ed and Instacart about to ipo, that's not a bad batch from a purely investment perspective.

Re: What I’ve learned from users

#79

Caveat - The best type of mentors for founders are other founders. VCs, Incubators, are not optimal mentors, rather those are key folks to have in your pocket. My suggestion for all founders - find a mentor who is a founder & builder.

Pretty much every YC partner is a founder and builder.

Re: What I’ve learned from users

#80
post #53

More of a meta discussion, but it's interesting that pretty much all HN threads on PG's recent essays have a strong, negative sentiment. My guess is that this is explained by 3 factors: 1) The quantity and quality of new ideas in PG's essays is declining. 2) Readers' expectations of quality in PG's essays is increasing. 3) The pool of disenfranchised readers is growing. The quantity and quality of new ideas is decrea…

Is there a single example of someone who is highly regarded for an extended period of time that doesnt end up having a strong group of people who dislike them?

It's hard to tell if there is just enough commenters on HN that dislike PG or if tech folks in general actually have decided to dislike PG.

Regardless, almost every single public figure reputation takes a downturn given enough time. PG is no exception.

Post reply on HN