Live data from Hacker News

Please Poach Me

pleasepoach.me

71–80 of 126 posts

Re: Please Poach Me

#71
post #48
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless they happen to read your resume and see that your experience directly lines up with what your company/team is working on?

Or they see requests to pleasepoach.me in their network logs, which depending on their resolution can nail you to a wall pretty easily.

Who goes job-hunting from their work computer?

Re: Please Poach Me

#72
If the job market for the target audience is so great (which it is), a service like this doesn't make sense. You'll only attract employees who are not competitive. Also, grammar check your landing. Even the first sentence has an error.

Re: Please Poach Me

#73
post #29
post #13

I'd love "pleasestoptryingtopoach.me".

I got a call from a recruiter recently. Turns out he thinks I'll be a great candidate to be the new CEO of some algorithmic trading/financial services company in New York City...given my decades of experience in the field. MBA required. I'm a 21-year-old who just took a leave of absence to concentrate on Kout.me ; how is it that I'm even a target of these people yet?

They're desperate, and they get paid a lot if everything goes well. They could carefully screen each person for exact suitability, throw out bad matches and bring in only a few good ones. Or they could throw huge numbers of resumes and see if any stick.

If the recruiter doesn't have excellent technical judgement (few do), the approaches basically pay the same.

Re: Please Poach Me

#74
post #71
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or they see requests to pleasepoach.me in their network logs, which depending on their resolution can nail you to a wall pretty easily.

Who goes job-hunting from their work computer?

You'd be surprised.

Re: Please Poach Me

#75

This is connected to an employee's LinkedIn profile, so why wouldn't an employee just change their contact settings to "I am open to career opportunities"? I know a lot of people that have that setting on, even if they are very happy with their job, and I don't know of a single person who has gotten flak for it from their employer.

Unfortunately that's very error-prone from the potential employer side. It's not a very strong signal that they're actually looking.

Re: Please Poach Me

#76
post #67
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, in recruiting you pay nothing until one lump sump when you hire someone. Here, you pay EACH TIME, and it adds up (even if it adds up to less than 20% recruiting fee, it still feels like constantly paying)

That's true but once an agency finds the right candidate you have to pay a lot to hire him/her, like 3 months salary.

I am a recruiter. My team and I charge by the hour.

Re: Please Poach Me

#77

I work at LinkedIn, so I think I'm reasonably qualified to provide my opinion. I'm certain that this won't work well. Charging $5 per profile view ($50 per 10) is simply outrageous. Most profiles will be junk or irrelevant - recruiters work very hard to sift through the chaff. Even of those that ARE relevant, there's a small chance they'll wind up working at your company. You'd have to have an unprecedented algorithm…

"Charging $5 per profile view ($50 per 10) is simply outrageous."

Is it? How much do (large|small|startup|) companies pay for recruiting? In my experience, referral bonuses paid to employees are thousands of dollars for a single candidate. In aggregate (staffing, advertising, sites like LinkedIn and pleasepoach.me that provide some quality of filtering) it has to be a lot.

It comes down to how well pleasepoach.me can match candidates to your organization per dollar versus other methods.

Re: Please Poach Me

#78

This is connected to an employee's LinkedIn profile, so why wouldn't an employee just change their contact settings to "I am open to career opportunities"? I know a lot of people that have that setting on, even if they are very happy with their job, and I don't know of a single person who has gotten flak for it from their employer.

Unfortunately that's very error-prone from the potential employer side. It's not a very strong signal that they're actually looking.

Very true. However, the impression I've gotten from recruiters emailing me is that most of them are just sending uncustomized emails to a lot of people who match some keywords. If that is the case, then contacting 100 people instead of to 25 people means an extra hour of work. I don't think it's worth paying $5/contact to avoid something that takes so little time.

Re: Please Poach Me

#79
post #77

I work at LinkedIn, so I think I'm reasonably qualified to provide my opinion. I'm certain that this won't work well. Charging $5 per profile view ($50 per 10) is simply outrageous. Most profiles will be junk or irrelevant - recruiters work very hard to sift through the chaff. Even of those that ARE relevant, there's a small chance they'll wind up working at your company. You'd have to have an unprecedented algorithm…

"Charging $5 per profile view ($50 per 10) is simply outrageous." Is it? How much do (large|small|startup| ) companies pay for recruiting? In my experience, referral bonuses paid to employees are thousands of dollars for a single candidate. In aggregate (staffing, advertising, sites like LinkedIn and pleasepoach.me that provide some quality of filtering) it has to be a lot. It comes down to how well pleasepoach.me ca…

However referral bonuses are paid only if your proposed candidate works through trial period (e.g. 3 months). You are paid for fish in the net not for fish in the sea.

Re: Please Poach Me

#80

I like the idea. Two implementation critiques: 1) Let recruiters see the value before making them pay (e.g. wait until people want to reach out to somebody). 2) Come up with payment terms that don't discourage use. You want people to pay you and then use your service religiously. Per-use pricing forces people to ration the extent that they use your service which gets in the way of maximizing the value you provide the…

I agree. There's no way I'm giving over my credit card details and being pre-billed when I have no idea if there is even anyone registered to be poached.

Take a lead from dating sites - tease and squeeze.

Post reply on HN