Live data from Hacker News

Why the Ukraine Crisis is the West's Fault (2014) [pdf]

mearsheimer.com

71–74 of 74 posts

Re: Why the Ukraine Crisis is the West's Fault (2014) [pdf]

#71
post #70

The crux of the argument is since the West is expanding NATO then it's the West's fault. Excuse me - what does national sovereignty mean? If the Ukraine desires to join NATO and NATO desires to have the Ukraine join then that's the Ukraine's prerogative as a sovereign nation. It's also Russia's prerogative to invade a sovereign nation, but they should fully expect to pay a price for that - up to and including all-out…

>Ukraine desires to join NATO

Do phrases like this have any meaning, in a world where politicians cut out borders through parts of the world that are traditionally multi cultural and have a huge diversity in opinions?

Re: Why the Ukraine Crisis is the West's Fault (2014) [pdf]

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Putin never actually wanted to join NATO, some of his demands were that as Russia joins there is no more need for any US presence in Europe as well as he wanted Russia to be exempt from rule of law and the democracy requirements that NATO has.

Wait... Isn't Italy in NATO?

Haha funny joke. Turkey would be a better example due to recent events but Spain is a more appropriate historic example as it wasn’t allowed to join until 1982.

Re: Why the Ukraine Crisis is the West's Fault (2014) [pdf]

#73
post #62
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People are very much missing this point; there is no value judgement here over what "should" be happening. There has always been clear red line; if NATO is attacked, we're starting WWIII. If a non-NATO friendly country is attacked, we'll complain loudly and declare sanctions. Ukraine is not in NATO and we should've behaved accordingly (i.e, not sponsor a coup)

"We" (whoever that is) did not "sponsor a coup". Stop spreading misinformation. What happened was that the Ukrainian people were sick of Russian puppet and kicked him out - at great cost, he murdered a lot of them.

It wouldn’t surprise me if it was a coup. Don’t forget Biden and his sons “business” there. It’s at the very least a valid theory.

Re: Why the Ukraine Crisis is the West's Fault (2014) [pdf]

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wait... Isn't Italy in NATO?

Haha funny joke. Turkey would be a better example due to recent events but Spain is a more appropriate historic example as it wasn’t allowed to join until 1982.

But I'm (ethnically) Italian so I feel a bit safer being judgemental :)
Post reply on HN