Live data from Hacker News

Unloved by generations of soldiers, the MRE finds a fan base

nytimes.com

71–80 of 105 posts

Re: Unloved by generations of soldiers, the MRE finds a fan base

#71
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

MREs self-heat. Hot food is good for morale and in a disaster situation, instant noodles might be "noodle crackers".

A pocket rocket and canister of isobutane is cheap and will never expire though. Problem solved.

You'd better have good ventilation though which might not be the case in some kind of "bunker".

Re: Unloved by generations of soldiers, the MRE finds a fan base

#72
post #29
post #26

Ah the venerable MRE. We had a nickname for these in the Army: Meals Refusing to Exit. It was also fabled that the beans and weenies meal could transform any infantryman into an airborne through flatulence alone.

I mean, excessive regularity during combat could be a liability, couldn't it?

The opposite is also true and more dangerous: it means you'll need medical attention sooner or later.

Re: Unloved by generations of soldiers, the MRE finds a fan base

#73
post #51

That pound cake that comes with many MREs is one of the best things I've ever tasted. It actually has a kind of fakey/chemically flavor to it (if I remember it's usually apple flavor?), but for some reason it's still good, and the moistness and texture of the cake is exceptional. I wish they just sold those pound cakes by themselves.

Out of a recent batch, I remember the lemon-poppyseed pound cake being amazing (as in, wouldn't have complained if I'd gotten it in a diner), a cookie that was rather good (actually moist!), and some really good cranberry mix. Also, the First Strike apple cinnamon energy bar was just as good as top-tier civilian energy bars. Entrees were a bit rougher. But as my dad paraphrased re: Boy Scouts, 'Hunger is a helluva sp…

You're right: I have fasted for 15 days a couple years ago: after that everything tasted absolutely amazing!

Re: Unloved by generations of soldiers, the MRE finds a fan base

#74
post #45
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've had Chinese MREs, once. It was the worst food I've ever tasted. Someone in the family had a can from former prc military service. I don't know what it is, but maybe the Chinese army deploys so infrequently (almost never?) that they place zero priority on their MREs. I begrudgingly eat US MREs once every 3-5 years for about a week or so as I replenish my one case of MREs for earthquake supplies. They're actually…

>I begrudgingly eat US MREs once every 3-5 years for about a week or so as I replenish my one case of MREs for earthquake supplies. What's the TCO on using MREs for disaster prep? I did some light research a while ago and figured it was pretty pricey compared to buying traditional nonperishables (eg. instant noodles, canned vegetables, dried beans). Plus, those foods are easier to work into a conventional meal than M…

Depends on what kind of disaster you're prepping for. In a severe disaster, you may not have power/gas for cooking, may not have much access to clean water, and may not be able to leave your home or have assistance come to you if roads are out. MREs don't require any water to prepare the main entrees, don't require any cooking, and have shelf lives of at least 5 years from the packing date (longer if stored at low temperature), and are meant to be easily transportable if you do have to evacuate in a hurry.

That being said, MREs are kind of overkill. The US military also uses called first-strike rations (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Strike_Ration) each of which are half the weight of the 3 MREs they replace and that are mostly centered around stabilized sandwiches and wraps. The manufacturer of those sandwiches, Bridgford, also sells to the civilian market: https://www.bridgford.com/readytoeat/ If you don't mind the much more limited menu (it's a disaster after all), a case of those sandwiches will keep a person fed for a couple weeks for much less than the cost and space of MREs.

Re: Unloved by generations of soldiers, the MRE finds a fan base

#77
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Night Watch series books talk about “fake vodka” which I found highly amusing. I assume it’s watered back industrial ethanol?

Normal vodka is diluted industrial ethanol. A very diverse range of spirits are bottled from the same train tanker cars of industrial ethanol, optionally adulterated with flavoring and coloring. I used to have friends that ran a bottling plant for state-wide distribution of several hundred well-known brands. All of their alcohol came from ADM in bulk. Not all spirits are produced this way but the vast majority are. T…

where are you talking about? Russia? US?

Re: Unloved by generations of soldiers, the MRE finds a fan base

#79
post #8
post #2

Steve1989MREInfo https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2I6Et1JkidnnbWgJFiMeHA Nice!

I love this guy's channel. He's the only guy I've seen who has the guts to eat MRE's dated since WWII and perhaps older. The most recent I've seen was him comparing MRE's from the PRC (yes, China), Taiwan, USA, Russia, etc.

I remember watching one of his older videos where he zoomed in on a package as he was trying to open it. I couldn't help but notice the very bad tremor in his hands. Made me wonder if the toxins in old MREs he's been eating have somehow contributed to that. Nonetheless, a very interesting channel for sure.

Re: Unloved by generations of soldiers, the MRE finds a fan base

#80
post #52
post #7

Wornick, which makes most of the real MREs, used to sell a civilian version. Their brand was "MIL-SPEC", and then "Eversafe". Now they don't seem to want to sell those at retail, probably because they normally ship by the shipping container load and the eBay resellers can't handle that much product. Everybody seems to be out of stock on civilian MREs right now, except for resellers who are doubling the price. (Each m…

> expired Was curious about this, as it's something of an open question as to the actual safe "absolutely-by" date (vs the standard date). Turns out, they've been tested to degrade at a rate proportional to temperature. The listed date (3 years?) is essentially 3 years at max temperature. Decrease the temperature (i.e. outside anywhere but the desert), and it stretches significantly. Actually store it somewhere cool…

When I did my mandatory service in the German army, we were told that MREs don't have an expiry date - batches are simply inspected once a year or so.
Post reply on HN