Live data from Hacker News

Today I launched my solo project, Listry. Feedback/suggestions appreciated

listry.com

71–80 of 85 posts

Re: Today I launched my solo project, Listry. Feedback/suggestions appreciated

#72

Kudos on a well implemented use of AppEngine - It's really zippy. Do you have any plans to write a technical overview of your implementation?

Thanks. I'll probably write about the implementation once I get some spare time. I got a lot of great feedback today that I'll be busy implementing for a while :)

Re: Today I launched my solo project, Listry. Feedback/suggestions appreciated

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From this being the top comment, it seems everyone agrees. I'll add it to my to-do list :)

Should I keep the 5 star rating control for rating articles, and change the voting on items to thumbs up/down? Or should I change both the voting on items and voting on articles to thumbs up/down?

Both articles and items should have the up/down vote options, rather than the 5 star, IMO.

There may be value in the determination of consumer-side article rank by a (weighted) average that encompasses both the net rank of items posted to the article + the rank of the article itself.

I'm sure you've already thought about the item/article interaction in terms of effect on overall article ranking. UI/X-side, the effect (of ranking an item within an article) is unclear now, and I am fine with that as an early user.

Moving forward, developing a ranking formula that weighs article rank against net rank of all of the article's items will be a usage-informed improvement that provides great value to users.

That ranking formula, as well as making the result of a "ranking" interaction obvious to the user, will help the understanding of how such interactions work.

With a social answering/ranking/voting application, creation of, and/or tweaks to, the formula that determines the effect of interactions will have a huge influence in shaping the culture of the individuals that interact with the application.

Re: Today I launched my solo project, Listry. Feedback/suggestions appreciated

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From this being the top comment, it seems everyone agrees. I'll add it to my to-do list :)

Should I keep the 5 star rating control for rating articles, and change the voting on items to thumbs up/down? Or should I change both the voting on items and voting on articles to thumbs up/down?

Think about it from a game theory perspective. If the rating of something is higher than you would like it to be, why would you vote more than a 1? If the rating is lower, why would you vote less than a 5?

Some people may express their honest preference, but a major motivation for people to interact with something like this is to change the average, and voting at the extremes maximizes their power.

Re: Today I launched my solo project, Listry. Feedback/suggestions appreciated

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From this being the top comment, it seems everyone agrees. I'll add it to my to-do list :)

Should I keep the 5 star rating control for rating articles, and change the voting on items to thumbs up/down? Or should I change both the voting on items and voting on articles to thumbs up/down?

Judging from the concept of "decision fatigue" outlined in that NY Times article the other day * , you're better off with thumbs up/down since it's less work to decide that than to have to choose 2 or 3 or 4 stars for an OK article.

* https://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/21/magazine/do-you-suffer-fr...

Post reply on HN