Live data from Hacker News

Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

zdnet.com

71–80 of 81 posts

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#71
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I actually have the opposite complaint. I would like my doctor to have access to info from my Apple Watch. Certainly I trained before a smart watch but I didn't necessarily know how fast I was going, if my metrics (like v02 max) were improving, how its affecting my heart, etc. Why would I care if Tim Cook could theoretically look up my resting bpm?

Substitute 'Tim Cook' for 'law enforcement', 'theoretically' for 'warrantless fishing expedition', 'resting bpm' for 'location' & 'known associates' & 'search terms' & 'browser history'.

Those things seem more related to smartphones than smart watches.

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#72
post #43

(2019) Go buy a Fitbit today. Incredibly, against all odds according to this article, you still can. They make new ones every 6 months. They may not have the high-performance 60hz display tech of the AW, but look past that and its a better experience than AW (and I use an iPhone; I still prefer Fitbit). Week long battery life on all models. Truly continuous heart rate monitoring (versus AW's "I'll take a reading mayb…

What I want is a fitness tracker that doesn't require me to create an account or store data in the cloud, where I can just transfer the data to my computer using USB or Bluetooth or something like that. Apparently I'm the only one because such a thing doesn't seem to exist.

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#73
post #43

(2019) Go buy a Fitbit today. Incredibly, against all odds according to this article, you still can. They make new ones every 6 months. They may not have the high-performance 60hz display tech of the AW, but look past that and its a better experience than AW (and I use an iPhone; I still prefer Fitbit). Week long battery life on all models. Truly continuous heart rate monitoring (versus AW's "I'll take a reading mayb…

What I want is a fitness tracker that doesn't require me to create an account or store data in the cloud, where I can just transfer the data to my computer using USB or Bluetooth or something like that. Apparently I'm the only one because such a thing doesn't seem to exist.

Such things do exist, particularly for medical purposes. What type of "fitness tracker" are you after? Explain more and I am certain that i can offer at least three sensing devices that suit your needs that record data offline.

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#74
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Substitute 'Tim Cook' for 'law enforcement', 'theoretically' for 'warrantless fishing expedition', 'resting bpm' for 'location' & 'known associates' & 'search terms' & 'browser history'.

Those things seem more related to smartphones than smart watches.

Your smartphone is a sensing devices that can record medical and fitness measures. So it is important to raise alongside a wristband

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#75
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What I want is a fitness tracker that doesn't require me to create an account or store data in the cloud, where I can just transfer the data to my computer using USB or Bluetooth or something like that. Apparently I'm the only one because such a thing doesn't seem to exist.

Such things do exist, particularly for medical purposes. What type of "fitness tracker" are you after? Explain more and I am certain that i can offer at least three sensing devices that suit your needs that record data offline.

Something that could monitor heart rate and rhythm, steps, sleep, breathing, that sort of thing. Blood pressure if that is even possible.

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#76
post #59

I opened the article expecting to agree with it, then I got to the part about "does anyone use google flights instead of travelocity " and started to wonder if it was satire.

Flights is my fourth favorite Google product after Search, Maps, and Translate. I used it all the time when travel was a bit more feasible and I hope to make use of it a lot in the future. As a traveler, it's powerful.

Google Travel was also great if you wanted to get a quick overview of what to see in a new city.

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#77
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do people give their health data to Silicon Valley corporations? I just don't get it. Didn't people train before the advent of "smart" watches?

I actually have the opposite complaint. I would like my doctor to have access to info from my Apple Watch. Certainly I trained before a smart watch but I didn't necessarily know how fast I was going, if my metrics (like v02 max) were improving, how its affecting my heart, etc. Why would I care if Tim Cook could theoretically look up my resting bpm?

In the future you could have a hard time getting insurance, because they bought that data and can tell you’re going to require expensive care soon.

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#78
post #43

(2019) Go buy a Fitbit today. Incredibly, against all odds according to this article, you still can. They make new ones every 6 months. They may not have the high-performance 60hz display tech of the AW, but look past that and its a better experience than AW (and I use an iPhone; I still prefer Fitbit). Week long battery life on all models. Truly continuous heart rate monitoring (versus AW's "I'll take a reading mayb…

Apple Watch is more of a mini-computer with apps than a heartbeat tracker. You can install separate fitness tracker apps for tracking fitness.

A heartbeat tracker doesn’t provide the same amount of value.

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#79
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why wouldn't people use Expedia? Honest question. I don't use it a lot; I usually book air and hotel direct. I do use other services as well on occasion but Expedia can be useful for discovery if nothing else.

All personal anecdotes but: Flights - wierd fare classes that dont have the normal options re changes and cancellation, no recourse through the airline if there are any issues Customer service - hours on hold, and you have to call them to change anything, the hotel/ airline wants nothing to do with you Hotels- treated like a 3rd class citizen, no points, cant use your status if you have it, worst room, I have been ch…

You have support with Expedia. Do you have it with Google?

Re: Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)

#80
post #21

I don't know the fate of Fitbit, although I can guess, but the fate of Samsung's anything connected with Tizen is pure DOOM. Why does Tizen spell DOOM? It is a huge C system that traffics exclusively in pointers to void. Yes: it is full of typedefs to void*. Do you need to know anything else? So, in whichever way Google flubs Fitbit, at least Samsung is out of their way. My question is, what has gone so very, very wr…

Wait until you write your first win32 program! WPARAM and LPARAM! Integer or pointer or unused?
Post reply on HN