Live data from Hacker News

The Reshaped Mac Experience

morrick.me

71–80 of 82 posts

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#71
This article felt vague and snooty to me personally because it was heavy on the negativity and light on the details.

Only after the article is more than half done, do they mention padding as a specific complaint, and that's it, the only issue in the entire article is padding.

Another article which exists to make the author feel superior? At least if you're gonna rant, make it worth the reader's time with a bunch of specific examples for us to tweak...

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Consumer silicon components have an predicted life span of 5-7 years†. This life span gets lower the smaller we go with chip technology. So, yes, a 5 year old computer is near retirement age. † https://c3.nasa.gov/dashlink/static/media/other/ObservedFail...

That's a pretty lousy estimated lifetime. If that is truly the case, it feels like planned obsolsense, as the rate of improvement in computing power has drastically slowed.

I figure it's a tradeoff. Speed and cost vs. lifespan.

(Effectively) Irreplacable batteries already limit the lifespan of many consumer devices to 3-4 years, so why limit the capabilities of the hardware to get a few years that won't be usable anyways… is how I imagine those conversations going.

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#73
post #2

The author makes the assertion that if we are all celebrating Apple's latest hardware, it is because the focus on their user interface has faded into the background and they have lost their way. But reading through the piece the only tangible evidence he provides is more spacing between elements that he is pulling up on 5 year old hardware? Screen density and pixels have improved dramatically in that time frame, we h…

Frankly, I'd point to where you say so yourself:

> Not every new interface will work equally well on old hardware, but that doesn't mean that the interface has deteriorated.

Apple is well-known for long support periods on mobile, and 5 years is not, in my eyes, an old computer that ought to be replaced. And so if the interface doesn't work as well on the authors supported hardware, then I think we can agree the interface has objectively deteriorated.

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#74

I must say I struggle to show sympathy for this Apple bashing blog post. Just look at the screenshot they post to illustrate their point. Its almost as if they have deliberately configured their system to make a point. The resolution is obscenely large (sorry, don't know the tech term). They have all their finder windows configured to use large icons. Seriously ?!? Only pure beginners do that. Their longwinded rant i…

>Just look at the screenshot they post to illustrate their point. Its almost as if they have deliberately configured their system to make a point.

Seriously. I can configure an iMac G4 to 1024x768 and immediately proclaim how space-inefficient OS X Panther is

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can have two apps in full screen mode side by side I personally really enjoy full screen mode when using my laptop undocked

Full screen and split screen have become my default modes of using almost everything on macOS. It's a pleasant, generally better focused, way of interacting. I just wish it were richer like the tiling WMs I used on Linux. Maybe not as useful on a laptop (due to screen size and my aging eyes), but when attached to a high res monitor it would be nice to be able to split the screen into quarters, at least, instead of ha…

This is also what I generally want and we're not alone. There are a few active projects to facilitate this. Personally I like Tiles" rel="nofollow">https://freemacsoft.net/tiles/">Tiles

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#76
post #9

I'm not too fond of the extra spacing and padding on Big Sur either. It reduces information density. All in preparation for a MacBook Touch?

>All in preparation for a MacBook Touch?

I doubt it, the spacing isn't enough to accommodate touch and they have constantly said they don't want to go down that road. They just need to look at the mess Microsoft created to see it isn't a good idea.

I think it's far more likely that they wanted the same design language across platforms.

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#77
post #17
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Screen density and pixels have improved dramatically in that time frame, we have larger screens, more resolution, and retina display I'm typing this on a new 13" MacBook Air, and the screen is pretty small! don't know if BigSur is optimized for a 27" iMac display, but on a small laptop, I certainly feel like the decreased UI density feels like a hindrance.

One of my minor bugbears with macOS since Yosemite has been changing the green button from zoom to full screen. I just don't use full screen mode much. On my 25" displays the only application that gets kept full screen is my IDE. I don't need a dedicated button that slowly animates the window to fullscreen if I accidentally click it. Speculating here, but given that most people using a mac are looking at a 13" screen…

Just in case you weren't already aware, you can hold Option when you click on the green + and it'll Zoom instead of going full screen. I'm the same way as you in that I don't really use full screen too much but I can understand that most people prefer their browser and email and stuff in full screen so that being the default makes sense to me.

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can have two apps in full screen mode side by side I personally really enjoy full screen mode when using my laptop undocked

ummm, how? When I hit the green button for full screen, it takes over the screen like a Spaces screen. How are you able to have side by side full screen of 2 apps. That seems like you are breaking the definition of the word full. If 2 apps are "full" screen side by side, you either have "half" screen views or 2 monitors.

Press and hold the "full screen" button and you'll get the option to go full screen with 2 apps.

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#79
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. I don't disagree with the fact that the OS and UI team seem a little less focused on the polish of the entire experience but the leaps in hardware are just too great to be able to keep up appropriately in the UI. They really just need to get back to ironing out the every day things. Case in point - not being able to reply to a Message directly from the notification is a huge regression. Fix stuff like that f…

> the leaps in hardware are just too great to be able to keep up appropriately in the UI Why would this be the case? Apple's a massive, well-resourced company and it seems like they should be able to walk and chew gum at the same time.

This is just an opinion but I'm a big fan of Apple and have been using their machines for a long time. There are just some new conventions that have been introduced alongside hardware that add complexity that I don't think is possible to get right the first time around outside of some pretty minimum functionality. Any time an process needs to be re-thought or redefined, you're basically starting from scratch even if the end results look similar. In the example I gave, Notification Center was something that had to be ported over from iPadOS/iOS (and I'm glad it did as I find it very useful and much more consistent of an experience) but it then needed to be retro-fit to handle applications that weren't originally intended for it. It also needs to deal with notifications in a way that make them consistent so that new users pick up the basics of how it works easily. To me, that's a hard task. I just wish there was a bit more consideration taken towards keeping existing functionality in place, even if it contradicts new paradigms, but that's really a design choice that I just have to disagree with because the alternative is probably better for most people using the machines. If it's not, the analytics will bear that out and they'll change it to the one that I prefer.

Re: The Reshaped Mac Experience

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. I don't disagree with the fact that the OS and UI team seem a little less focused on the polish of the entire experience but the leaps in hardware are just too great to be able to keep up appropriately in the UI. They really just need to get back to ironing out the every day things. Case in point - not being able to reply to a Message directly from the notification is a huge regression. Fix stuff like that f…

There are many things in macOS that have not been looked at properly. That has nothing to do with hardware. It's plain sloppyness.

I disagree. I think it has everything to do with hardware because the software has to work with the hardware. The teams more than likely focus on making sure new hardware works with the OS as a priority and focus on the "nice to haves" for point releases. Rosetta, for example, probably took up a large chunk of time in the latest release and that has to extend to nearly every aspect of the UI to make sure that notifications, power management, and resource management all work properly with both new and existing apps on both ARM and x64 versions.
Post reply on HN