Live data from Hacker News

Hire people who give a shit

alexw.substack.com

71–80 of 342 posts

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#71
post #3

Was pretty decent till I got to "I have a particular line of questioning around this" Now we equate "giving a shit" to how many hours you put in. Should we just go back to counting lines of code to view effort?

I won't say I especially like it up to that point. But that was maybe because I was already doing the passion=hours translation in my head. But at least he's honest about it at that point.

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#72

I have a genuine question and I'm not trying to be snarky -- do people actually think this way in real life, or is it an elaborate social game of pretending to be more "passionate" than the next guy? Scale seems like a cool company with an interesting product, but let's be honest, rational people here - they aren't curing cancer, creating art, or landing on Normandy Beach. This seems obvious to any self-aware person.…

> "I have a genuine question and I'm not trying to be snarky -- do people actually think this way in real life, or is it an elaborate social game of pretending to be more "passionate" than the next guy?" We have a slight issue with 'identity' in the US. I need to read more Tocqueville before I really start espousing any diagnostic on the psyche of the US but... This type of mindset is what occurs when someone searche…

[deleted]

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#73
The article starts off well, but then goes wildly wrong in the end.

"Giving a shit" is orthogonal to working long hours. As a part of my job, I hire people and one thing I tell all candidates is: "I expect you to care about your work. This does not mean that you have to work evenings or weekends. But while you are working, you should care about doing a good job."

It's certainly partially about believing that you are working on the right thing, but mainly about believing the craft matters.

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#74
post #57

Not a native speaker, but for me "giving a shit" doesn't sound like you really care for something. Ok, it's (maybe) better than "not giving a shit", which is nothing at all, but it's not much more than the bare minimum...

You're not wrong at all

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#75
>Ultimately, you’re searching for people you’d be willing to spend every waking moment with, since if things go right, there will be many long nights.

Lots of hours at this place eh?

>What’s the hardest you’ve ever worked on something?

What happened to work smart not hard? Also what exactly does it mean to work hard as a developer?

>How many hours were you working a week?

Hours again eh? Sounds like this place has absolutely no work-life balance and just burns everyone out. To whose benefit? Oh right only the benefit of the CEO.

>For example, it’s absolutely shocking that the common paradigm for engineers at Google is to come in at 11am and leave at 4pm. In no world can you be working 5 hours a day and be giving a shit, and so the conclusion is that very little meaningful work gets done at Google.

This has to be the dumbest thing I have read in ages.

Google has a market capitalization of 1.2 trillion. They have extensive research into how to treat employees to maximize their productivity. If you think google is doing it wrong, you are indeed the one doing it wrong.

> lack of office attires

You can tell this guy has a dress code. Even General Motors the place of 10 layers of bureaucracy discovered they dont need a dress code.

Working for this guy sounds like a nightmare.

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#76

And the inverse: have a business which is worthy of shit-giving. It’s extremely hard to give a shit about Yet Another Middleware CRUD CRM Layer Corp. There’s a fine balancing point between working a bullshit job ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs ) and recognizing that no, the B-Ark ( https://hitchhikers.fandom.com/wiki/Golgafrinchan_Ark_Fleet_... ) is a bad idea, we really do need telephone handset saniti…

> And the inverse: have a business which is worthy of shit-giving.

This is a corollary. The inverse would be "hire people who don't give a shit."

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#78
> The uncomfortable truth is that most people don’t give a shit. For example, it’s absolutely shocking that the common paradigm for engineers at Google is to come in at 11am and leave at 4pm. In no world can you be working 5 hours a day and be giving a shit, and so the conclusion is that very little meaningful work gets done at Google. Maybe a bit of a hyperbole, but not far from the truth. That culture is broken.

This statement shows how anti-worker this guy is. Good on such a Googler.

If you encounter a leader (like this guy) that thinks working hard for 8 hours a day is bare minimum (like this guy), do _not_ give them your labor if you can avoid it. You only have one life, so don't waste it making guys like this far richer than they would ever make you.

I hope plenty of BigCo and startup (especially Scale) employees are shaving hours with no repercussions thanks to Covid remote work. Such a huge effective hourly wage bump, and the only things harmed are corporations and their leaders (abstractly and relatively.)

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#79

I have a genuine question and I'm not trying to be snarky -- do people actually think this way in real life, or is it an elaborate social game of pretending to be more "passionate" than the next guy? Scale seems like a cool company with an interesting product, but let's be honest, rational people here - they aren't curing cancer, creating art, or landing on Normandy Beach. This seems obvious to any self-aware person.…

> "I have a genuine question and I'm not trying to be snarky -- do people actually think this way in real life, or is it an elaborate social game of pretending to be more "passionate" than the next guy?" We have a slight issue with 'identity' in the US. I need to read more Tocqueville before I really start espousing any diagnostic on the psyche of the US but... This type of mindset is what occurs when someone searche…

The real irony is that often the best work is only possible when you balance it with rest, family, and community. Writing for 12 hours a day probably isn't going to produce the next great American novel, so I'm skeptical that it will produce the next "great" startup either.

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#80
post #57

Not a native speaker, but for me "giving a shit" doesn't sound like you really care for something. Ok, it's (maybe) better than "not giving a shit", which is nothing at all, but it's not much more than the bare minimum...

You’re 100% correct in your interpretation of the strict grammatical meaning.

I think maybe ‘not giving a shit’ existed as a turn of phrase first, and ‘giving a shit’ is sometimes used (incorrectly in the grammatical sense, but ok in the colloquial sense) as the complete negation/opposite.

Post reply on HN