Live data from Hacker News

Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

sciencedirect.com

71–80 of 187 posts

Re: Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

#71
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Try getting prescribed seroquel instead. A lot more powerful, and will help you sleep. Less (known?) downsides as well. I guarantee you that you will be able to sleep with it.

Seroquel makes you wake up. at night and wanna eat chocolate. Too much of it makes you feel like a zombie the next day. SCAREQUEL should be the name. Ive sleep walked on that stuff

Lol, for me it's cheerios.

Re: Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

#72
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am happy that this works for you, but you can't really compare a Z-Drug with an atypical antipsychotic. That's some dangerous medical advice. Also (from wikipedia) on Seroquel / Quetiapine: "Despite being widely used as a sleep aid due its sedating effect, the benefits of such use do not appear to generally outweigh the side effects." https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/8812/afd4bc713c03435b68f2bb... Personally I woul…

I've taken it for over 10 years and am better than ever. Hasn't suffered any harmful side-effects either. Of course, side-effects differ from person to person. But it's worth a try. Z-drugs and benzos are way worse. Moreover, if you're severely addicted to Z-drugs like OP, the benefits probably do outweigh the side-effects. Not every person is the same, and the cost benefit analysis differs accordingly.

Antipsychotics ruined my life and gave me tardive dyskinesia.

Re: Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

#73
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Try getting prescribed seroquel instead. A lot more powerful, and will help you sleep. Less (known?) downsides as well. I guarantee you that you will be able to sleep with it.

I am happy that this works for you, but you can't really compare a Z-Drug with an atypical antipsychotic. That's some dangerous medical advice. Also (from wikipedia) on Seroquel / Quetiapine: "Despite being widely used as a sleep aid due its sedating effect, the benefits of such use do not appear to generally outweigh the side effects." https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/8812/afd4bc713c03435b68f2bb... Personally I woul…

This is a gross misunderstanding of what Seroquel is used for. It's one of those medications that several different side effects depending on the dosage.

Yes, it can be used as an anti-psychotic. However, in most of the cases I've heard, it's used as a sleep aid.

This was the case for me, too. I was on it for 10 years and ultimately went off because I grew out of my chronic insomnia. Aside from a muted personality and nightmares (the latter controlled by another medication), it was pretty fool proof and had very little consequence in my particular case.

As always, it depends on the person, but the blanket statement you quoted doesn't seem fair.

Re: Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

#74
post #11

Zolpidem, I use this pill to sleep and works fantastic for me. My MD told me that regular use could lead to dementia and the risk for addiction is considerable. I've tried antidepressants to sleep but always wake up with a headache, the feeling of it it's not great either. But with this one, never had an issue.

Take seroquel instead. Less risky, at least mentally. Also more powerful and effective.

Re: Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

#75
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Try getting prescribed seroquel instead. A lot more powerful, and will help you sleep. Less (known?) downsides as well. I guarantee you that you will be able to sleep with it.

I am happy that this works for you, but you can't really compare a Z-Drug with an atypical antipsychotic. That's some dangerous medical advice. Also (from wikipedia) on Seroquel / Quetiapine: "Despite being widely used as a sleep aid due its sedating effect, the benefits of such use do not appear to generally outweigh the side effects." https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/8812/afd4bc713c03435b68f2bb... Personally I woul…

Looks like that poster is in a completely different category from the general population. It says so in your quote as well: "does not appear to _generally_ outweigh the side effects".

That's a rather common mistake and I'd guess many doctors do it as well. Treatment risk depends only on alternatives. A pill that gives your a 0.01% chance of sudden death is an absolute no-go for genpop, but may be heaven-sent for a particular patient.

Re: Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

#76
post #72
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've taken it for over 10 years and am better than ever. Hasn't suffered any harmful side-effects either. Of course, side-effects differ from person to person. But it's worth a try. Z-drugs and benzos are way worse. Moreover, if you're severely addicted to Z-drugs like OP, the benefits probably do outweigh the side-effects. Not every person is the same, and the cost benefit analysis differs accordingly.

Antipsychotics ruined my life and gave me tardive dyskinesia.

Could you expound? It's always been in the back of my mind and I take a fairly low does, but would love to hear more about how it started, symptoms, and how it's affected your life.

I'm really sorry, that sucks. There is some new medication that is supposed to treat it (I think I saw an ad on TV for it).

Re: Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

#78
Found out promethazine (over the counter antihistamine) can make me sleepy after trying to use it to help with virtual reality sickness.

I've recently started taking it a few times a month to help out when I am having poor sleep, in an attempt to kick me back into a decent rhythm.

Reading the experiences in this thread of people using Seroquel or Zolpidem and their negative reactions - I am feeling a little sketchy about my crutch.

Re: Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

#79

Zolpidem is famous for this, although it’s raised more questions than answers. This particular phenomenon has been known since the early 2000s; NYT has a good write up about it: https://www.nytimes.com/2011/12/04/magazine/can-ambien-wake-...

Indeed, there was even a Dr House episode featuring it.

Re: Severe brain injury and paralysis temporarily reversed with a sleeping pill

#80
post #33

Ah, the video at the bottom of the paper is really emotional! I hope they can figure out how to prolong the effects. Still, an hour of lucidity and verbal communication and a stroll every few weeks and a visit with the family is infinitely better than nothing at all.

I'm glad you pointed that out. It was great to see video of him.

I wonder how does he feel when he's not under zolpidem. We can clearly see him being slow and mostly non-responsive, but I wonder what the experience for him is like - is it like sleep where he doesn't feel/remember anything about it (notice how once under zolpidem he does not think he has health problems), does he feel normal, and if so what is he thinking about, etc?
Post reply on HN