Live data from Hacker News

The New Facebook Design Sucks

jyssicaschwartz.medium.com

71–80 of 109 posts

Re: The New Facebook Design Sucks

#71

Facebook outlived its usefulness 8 or 9 years ago. If you're still using it in 2020, then you kind of deserve whatever you get.

If people are still using it in 2020, FB definitely provides something useful to their lives. Your tiny internet bubble does not represent the ~8 billion people living on Earth.

Re: The New Facebook Design Sucks

#72
A bit off-topic, but I always find it so interesting that the creators of React - the premier web UI framework - did such a poor job with Facebook on mobile web.

It’s borderline unusable, but I suspect this might be intentionally done to drive users to the mobile app.

Re: The New Facebook Design Sucks

#73

I have no opinion on the Facebook designs but I'm so tickled to see this post. What a blast from the past! I thought "the new Facebook design sucks" posts died out ten years ago :-D

Ha, I remember being in high school and having the same debate. I think users reject dramatic change but slowly get used to it. The exception is “new Reddit”, which is still widely disliked in favor of https://old.reddit.com.

Re: The New Facebook Design Sucks

#74
post #49

Posting about how the new Facebook design sucks on a blog which I can't read because the blogging platform sucks.

I have an idea for a revolutionary blogging platform, would you like to hear? It's kind of like facebook for wordpress with a twist. We're looking to raise $378M to have sufficient runway.

That's gonna require 200 engineers at SF rates. Better shoot for $0.5B if you want to be taken seriously.

Re: The New Facebook Design Sucks

#75
LOL at the people threatening to quit Facebook. Quitting Facebook is like "going off the grid" -- sure, some people do it, but 99% of the people who threaten to will never even get close, and the people who actually do it don't spend their time shouting about how they're going to do it.

Re: The New Facebook Design Sucks

#76
post #2

Less information density = more time required to read the same amount of content = more "engagement". This is the exact same reason behind the algorithmic timeline: since you can't easily tell whether you've reached the end (up to where you left off last time), you keep scrolling more, thus more time spent and more opportunities for ads to show up. This trend will continue until users revolt against this by refusing…

Algorithmic timelines have objective advantages: they can keep the most frequent posters from drowning everyone else. That's of course not to say they aren't maliciously misused.

the ability to easily filter/unfilter users from my feed is a much more user-friendly solution to that problem.

Re: The New Facebook Design Sucks

#78
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know, maybe I'm better about removing bad habits but when this happened to reddit I just stopped using the site. I don't even know what any of the facebook designs look like except whatever they had ~2007 though.

I still use old reddit, but if I'm logged out or somehow come across the new version, I just close the tab. It's just terrible, and I'll stop using the site when the old version is gone.

They have stated they will never remove old Reddit. And to an extent, I believe them. But instead what I think will happen is old Reddit will just slowly decay. Here is an example: https://old.reddit.com/r/Stepmania/comments/jg2ab2/remote_ar...

That link at the bottom is for a video. I can't figure out how to watch that video in old Reddit. But if you load this post up in new Reddit, the video plays in line.

Re: The New Facebook Design Sucks

#79
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Algorithmic timelines have objective advantages: they can keep the most frequent posters from drowning everyone else. That's of course not to say they aren't maliciously misused.

the ability to easily filter/unfilter users from my feed is a much more user-friendly solution to that problem.

It's not that simple is it?

I want to see the photos my crazy aunt posts of her family and dogs, but I would love to not see the alt-right political memes she also posts.

I can do this already to some extent by simply blocking certain sources that she's reposting from. It's harder to do when the content is copied and pasted.

Re: The New Facebook Design Sucks

#80

I have no opinion on the Facebook designs but I'm so tickled to see this post. What a blast from the past! I thought "the new Facebook design sucks" posts died out ten years ago :-D

Ha, I remember being in high school and having the same debate. I think users reject dramatic change but slowly get used to it. The exception is “new Reddit”, which is still widely disliked in favor of https://old.reddit.com .

As a service to the community, there's probably a redirect extension for whatever browser you're using that can be configured to take you directly to the "old Reddit" look-and-feel. For FireFox, I use Redirector and the following rule:

Redirect: https://www.reddit.com/(.*) to: https://old.reddit.com/$1 Example: https://www.reddit.com/r/HomeServer/https://old.reddit.com/r/HomeServer/

I also (apparently) use it to redirect mobile wikipedia to regular wikipedia.

Post reply on HN