Live data from Hacker News

Chrome killed my extension and won’t tell me why

blog.lipsurf.com

71–73 of 73 posts

Re: Chrome killed my extension and won’t tell me why

#71
This happened to us by Google just now too. They deleted our app for a violation in version one of the app when we are on version 4 (over a year later) after 100 emails with basic replies, and inability to escalate we are at a loss. This is for Google Play store. Serves us right to try and build a business on Google/Android

Re: Chrome killed my extension and won’t tell me why

#72
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Publishers need authors to make money, google doesn’t need extension developers.

In theory, Chrome works fine without extensions. In practice, if Chrome was "banned by the Extension developers' guild" so that every other browser got to participate in the WebExtension ecosystem except for Chrome, people would leave Chrome quickly. (Sadly, probably for some "exactly Chrome, but not by Google" browser, rather than for Firefox.)

People won’t leave chrome quickly or at all, Chrome didn’t win the battle of the browsers due to having better or more extensions it won because of 3 major factors.

Better brand recognition - more people switched off IE to Chrome than from FF to chrome (hence why I’m not putting the terrible performance and reliability issues that FF used to have like crash and lose all tabs as a factor but it took a decade for FF to sort their shit together and by then it was too late).

Better integration with Google services right when a Google account became quite important.

Being the default browser for the Android eco system.

So I don’t know who would exactly leave Chrome because of extensions but I have a feeling that even you wouldn’t.

Re: Chrome killed my extension and won’t tell me why

#73
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This seems like more a solution to open, transparent platforms. It’s a shame that we are going backwards: you used to be able to download software from the internet, direct from publishers with no limitations. Now everything’s all stupid requiring developers to beg the “powers that be” for access to distribute their work.

But that isn't sustainable anymore now that everyone and their mother does all sorts of sensitive thing on the internet. App Stores may not catch any and all malware, but they'll catch some, or even a lot, and they give Google (or whoever runs one) tools to deal with what slips through. They make getting new extensions transparent and they're trustworthy. What's missing is legislation to level the playing field; eith…

Yeah I agree the legislation would help—but the legislators mostly don’t know much about tech I’m guessing. And the experts they call in I’d wager are from big companies with their own interests in mind.
Post reply on HN