Live data from Hacker News

Firefox 74

mozilla.org

71–80 of 269 posts

Re: Firefox 74

#71

It says a lot that there's a new feature bullet for Facebook alone. I wonder if at some point Firefox is going to be so effective at hampering FB's goals that FB decides it needs to be crushed

Firefox has (unfortunately) such an insignificant share that it doesn't make any difference. Also many companies don't even bother officially supporting it any more.

Re: Firefox 74

#73
post #14

The Facebook container is great, but I wish there was an option for the built-in Multi-Account containers to work this way. I've been doing what the Facebook Container extension does, but with built-in containers, and the experience is very clunky. The two biggest issues are that I can't give the container a list of domains beforehand and say "everything under google.com should open here". I have to go to each Google…

I wish every domain could automatically be opened in an individual container. I don't even need to know about them.

Ask and ye shall receive: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/temporary-con...

I use this in combination with "normal" containers and it works a treat

Re: Firefox 74

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> whenever I click a link on Gmail that goes to Github, Github opens in the Google container and I always have to copy/paste the address to a new tab. You can right-click links and open them in a "New Container Tab" (including "No Container"). Edit: You can also right-click on the tabs and select "Reopen in Container"

Sure, but it's not as convenient as doing it automatically.

I feel like that's probably by design. If you were in a session and clicking links, the assumption is if you're in the container already, you'd want to remain in the container. I don't disagree it would be nice for you to be able to specify domains per containers, but yeah, maybe that'll come in the future..

Re: Firefox 74

#75
post #14

The Facebook container is great, but I wish there was an option for the built-in Multi-Account containers to work this way. I've been doing what the Facebook Container extension does, but with built-in containers, and the experience is very clunky. The two biggest issues are that I can't give the container a list of domains beforehand and say "everything under google.com should open here". I have to go to each Google…

I wish every domain could automatically be opened in an individual container. I don't even need to know about them.

There's also the privacy.firstparty.isolate in about:config which isolates each site.

Re: Firefox 74

#76
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, but it's not as convenient as doing it automatically.

I feel like that's probably by design. If you were in a session and clicking links, the assumption is if you're in the container already, you'd want to remain in the container. I don't disagree it would be nice for you to be able to specify domains per containers, but yeah, maybe that'll come in the future..

It's definitely by design, since the containers are meant to segregate accounts (e.g. a company container and a personal container), but a second mode would be useful since many people are using them for per-site isolation.

Re: Firefox 74

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wish every domain could automatically be opened in an individual container. I don't even need to know about them.

That would break a lot of stuff, though. And then I don't just mean "bad" tracking, but normal auth flows etc

You're quite right - I have some trouble with "modal" popup windows and the Atlassian Single Sign On in particular with the temporary extensions tab. But I eventually figured out to copy and paste those URLs and manually whitelist them to a specific container tab

I wouldn't recommend it for family or friends, but I'm happy with the trade off

Re: Firefox 74

#78
post #68

Eagerly awaiting a Firefox release that improves power consumption on Mac to a point where it is at least close to competitive with Safari. That, plus the rumors that iOS will soon allow 3rd party default browsers and I'm all in Firefox for sure.

I'm on a 2019 Macbook Pro and my battery lasts for hours. Then again, I haven't run Safari for an extended period of time.

Re: Firefox 74

#79
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

With the base multi account container extension https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account... you can right click in any page and have it remember the container for that domain. For example you open abc.com in container "Personal" once, then you can tell it do remember to use that container whenever you go to abc.com. The Conex extension https://github.com/kesselborn/conex goes beyond by (optionally…

> you can tell it do remember to use that container whenever you go to abc.com My problem with that is that, even if I do this, it doesn't remember it for foo.abc.com, and when I'm in the container, links to def.com won't open outside the container.

I use Containise for that, it lets you set wildcards: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/containerise/

Re: Firefox 74

#80
Even if Facebook is containerized, if you make a purchase on .com they might just tell Facebook (without the browser involved)
Post reply on HN