Earlier quoted context omitted.
Yes, I do have musical anhedonia.
I think you may have something that I don't have, as I believe in more or less a zero sum game in terms of mental functions: e.g. a blind person develops other senses better such as hearing or spatial orientation etc. I'm on the opposite side of the spectrum, more like a music hedonist, though lately I started to enjoy silence just as much. Do you feel that you have some sense more developed than the norm?
What is music? A unified theory of music and dreaming
71–73 of 73 posts
Re: What is music? A unified theory of music and dreaming
#72What about war chants?
Then, after thinking these thoughts, find a piece of music that strongly intensifies the emotions which arise from thinking them. This music won't be an actual prehistoric war chant, because most of us living in the modern world have musical tastes that have been shaped by exposure to modern commercially produced music. So you will be thinking about a prehistoric war scenario, while listening to twentieth or twenty first century music.
Then, I think, you will understand, albeit subjectively, what it is that war chants are about.
Re: What is music? A unified theory of music and dreaming
#73What about war chants?
The best way to understand about war chants is, firstly, to imagine what it would be like to be a warrior in some prehistoric tribe that is about to go to war. Imagine possible scenarios in your future - the beginning of the war, where you and your fellow warriors carefully but deliberately proceed towards the enemy (who might be a neighbouring tribe who don't yet realise they are the enemy), the actual fighting, whe…